The Discourses

Niccolò Machiavelli
A free city does not last because one founder finished the design on day one. Machiavelli will not marvel at Rome's empire until he has asked who founded her, whether she began free, and which offices still work after that man is gone. He writes Discourses on Livy from a farm outside Florence, after the Medici have returned and closed the republican chancery he served for fourteen years. The commentary is printed in 1531, after his death. Livy is the file of cases. The Prince already showed how a new seat is taken. This book asks how a city keeps one when the chair is empty.
Machiavelli is the dismissed secretary. Livy supplies the Roman record. Rome had no Lycurgus and still mixed king, nobles, and people through accidents. The commons want not to be dominated. The senate already holds power. The tribunes are the office that quarrel produced. Florence is the hometown used as a recent proof: reformed in 1502 after Arezzo, ruined in 1512 after Prato. Readers who know only The Prince arrive last. They expect a licence to crush. They meet a republican who still assumes men go bad when nothing checks them.
A city that starts under another state's grace cannot grow past that master's leave. Florence, whether you give it to Sylla's soldiers or to the people of Fiesole coming down to the Arno, begins under Rome. Simple forms then fail. King, nobles, and commons each slide into their twin, and a neighbour can swallow the city before the circle finishes. After the Tarquins, the nobles spit the venom they had hidden, and tribunes are created so the people have an office that can stand. Those who call that tumult a defect, he says, condemn the cause of her becoming free. Liberty then needs a charge, not a rumour. Coriolanus is cited instead of torn apart leaving the senate house. A city that copies Venetian quiet to avoid that quarrel also copies a people too few to hold an empire. Book II answers Plutarch's temples to Fortune. Rome never fought two great wars at once because the sequence was a method, and she grew on citizen arms and companions, not on luck. Book III says mixed bodies rust. They last only if brought back to first beginnings, by law or by a rare man.
He is not writing a hymn to marble virtue, and he is not writing the opposite of The Prince. He still tells founders to assume that men are bad, and will show it when they have a free field. What he adds is the machinery that does not depend on one virtuous man: mixed offices, religion used as civic discipline, agrarian laws that can save a state or wreck it, citizen arms instead of hired ones, and the return to first principles that can heal or revenge. Brutus sits in judgment on his sons to keep the freedom he has won. Piero Soderini will not strike, and loses power, fame, and his country. Quintius Fabius, as censor, classes new citizens in four tribes and earns the name Maximus without a violent change. The ending is earned as a small ordinance, not as a crown.
The six lessons follow that pressure, not a catalogue of Roman names. Reading Republican Foundations is the origin that sets a ceiling, then the mix Rome stumbled into because no Lycurgus arrived with a finished book. Studying History as a Laboratory is Livy used as evidence, Florence 1502 and 1512 used as a recent proof, and Plutarch's Fortune temples answered with a method. Building Institutions That Outlast Founders is the consuls, the senate, and the tribunes: offices that survive the man who first sat in them. Managing Conflict Without Destroying the State is the tumult between commons and nobles, kept inside a charge so the missing popular share arrives without burning the city. Knowing When Reform Helps or Destroys is the agrarian law that reaches backward, Soderini's patience that will not strike, and the return to first principles that can heal or revenge. Keeping Liberty Under Pressure is Book III: captains, Hannibal and Scipio, Cincinnatus in poverty, and the last discourse's demand for new ordinances when the mischiefs are new.
Fabius does not wait for a new founder. As censor he classes new citizens in four tribes, keeps the suffrage from swallowing the state, and earns the name Maximus without a violent change. Wide Reads puts summaries, quotes, and audio on all thirty-nine editorial chapters, clustering one hundred and forty-two discourses from a farm that had already lost its chair. The next mischief will not wait either.
Lessons from The Discourses
Theme-by-theme chapter breakdowns of the essential skills in this classic work.
Lessons from The Discourses
Theme-by-theme chapter breakdowns of the essential skills in this classic work.Prestige deep dive
A Psychological Reading of The Discourses
The Discourses is the psychology of a city that cannot afford to experience freedom as a founder's character, so it staffs quarrel, rites, and new ordinances as the holding that remains after the chair is empty.
Read the full psychological readingDeep dives
Chapter-by-chapter breakdowns
Building Institutions That Outlast Founders
Track consuls, senate, and tribunes as offices that survive the man who first sat in them.
Managing Conflict Without Destroying the State
Keep quarrel inside a charge, as Coriolanus is cited instead of torn, so the missing office arrives without burning the city.
Table of Contents
Book I · 1–4: Of the beginnings of cities in general, and in particular of that of Rome.
Rome does not become a lasting free city because one founder finished the design on day one. Machiav...
Book I · 5–8: Whether the guardianship of public freedom is safer in the hands of the commons or of the nobles; and whether those who seek to acquire power or they who seek to maintain it are the greater cause of commotions.
Liberty lasts when the people who want not to be dominated hold the keys, and when anger has a lawfu...
Book I · 9–12: That to give new institutions to a commonwealth, or to reconstruct old institutions on an entirely new basis, must be the work of one man.
A new constitution must be the work of one man, but the act is excused only if the morning after pro...
Book I · 13–16: Of the use the Romans made of religion in giving institutions to their city, in carrying out their enterprises, and in quelling tumults.
Shared rites can pause a vote, send an army sure of success, and frighten a broken people into stand...
Book I · 17–20: That a corrupt people obtaining freedom can hardly preserve it.
Freedom handed to a corrupt people will not stay, no matter how loudly the palace changes its name. ...
Book I · 21–24: That it is a great reproach to a prince or to a commonwealth to be without a national army.
A city without its own army is not short of men. It is short of a ruler who knows how to make subjec...
Book I · 25–28: That he who would reform the institutions of a free state, must retain at least the semblance of old ways.
A man who would reform a free city must keep at least the look of the old ways, even when the new or...
Book I · 29–32: Whether a people or a prince is the more ungrateful.
Ingratitude has two springs: avarice and suspicion. A prince or a people sends a captain on an impor...
Book I · 33–36: When a mischief has grown up in, or against a state, it is safer to temporize with than to meet it with violence.
Forty nations notice Rome too late and combine to crush her. The usual Roman answer in peril is a di...
Book I · 37–40: Of the mischief bred in Rome by the Agrarian Law: and how it is a great source of disorder in a commonwealth to pass a law opposed to ancient usage and with stringent retrospective effect.
A law that reaches backward against old usage can split a city faster than the abuse it names. Men r...
Book I · 41–44: That it is unwise to pass at a bound from leniency to severity, or to a haughty bearing from a humble.
A sudden change of face can unmask you faster than the new hardness can work. Appius's fraud is skil...
Book I · 45–48: That it is of evil example, especially in the maker of a law, not to observe the law when made: and that daily to renew acts of injustice in a city is most hurtful to the governor.
It is of evil example, especially in the maker of a law, not to observe the law when made. Virginius...
Book I · 49–52: That if cities which, like Rome, had their beginning in freedom, have had difficulty in framing such laws as would preserve their freedom, cities which at the first have been in subjection will find this almost impossible.
If cities born in freedom still struggle to frame laws that keep them free, cities that began in sub...
Book I · 53–56: That the people, deceived by a false show of advantage, often desire what would be their ruin; and that large hopes and brave promises easily move them.
A people will take a course that looks profitable or spirited even when the country's death sits beh...
Book I · 57–60: That the people are strong collectively, but individually weak.
A multitude is strong while it holds together and weak as soon as each person thinks of a private da...
Common Questions About The Discourses
Trending search questions mapped to the six lessons in this treatise: what readers actually ask Google about Discourses on Livy versus The Prince, mixed government, tumults between orders, Livy as evidence, returning to first principles, and how a free city lasts after the founder.
What is The Discourses about?
Machiavelli writes from a farm outside Florence after the Medici return, asking which laws outlive the founder. Discourse I sorts cities that begin free or dependent. Florence, whether you give it to Sylla's soldiers or to Fiesole coming down to the Arno, starts under Rome's grace. Dinocrates then offers Alexander a city carved on Mount Athos in the shape of a man, and Alexander asks how the inhabitants will live.
Explore Reading Republican FoundationsHow is The Discourses different from The Prince?
The Prince is the short farm book on how a new seat is taken. This commentary, printed in 1531, asks how a free city keeps one after that man is gone. Consuls keep the kingly power without the throne. Tribunes are created so the people have an office between them and the senate. Readers who expect a licence to crush meet mixed offices instead.
Explore Building Institutions That Outlast FoundersWhy does Machiavelli use Livy in The Discourses?
Livy is a file of cases, not patriotic scenery. Machiavelli tests fortune against valour, money against actual force, and Hannibal's fear against Scipio's love, then keeps the result even when it spoils a popular summary. Florence, reformed in 1502 after Arezzo and ruined in 1512 after Prato, sits on the same bench as Rome.
Explore Studying History as a LaboratoryWhy does Machiavelli defend tumults in The Discourses?
After the Tarquins, the nobles spit the venom they had hidden, and tribunes are created from that quarrel. Guardianship of public freedom has to sit with nobles or commons, and both cause commotions. Tumult kept inside an office supplies the missing popular share. Peace that silences one order is a postponed war.
Explore Managing Conflict Without Destroying the StateWhat does returning to first principles mean in The Discourses?
Book III says mixed bodies last when change brings them back to their first beginnings. The agrarian law shows a reform that can wreck a city by opposing ancient usage with retrospective force. The last discourse asks for a physician: a free city that will not write new ordinances for new mischiefs will not stay free.
Explore Knowing When Reform Helps or DestroysWhat life lessons does The Discourses teach?
Six lessons run through the treatise: read how a city began before you praise its later empire; treat history as a laboratory of cases, not decoration; build offices that outlast the founder; keep quarrel inside the law so it finishes the mix instead of burning the city; time reform so it heals rather than revenges; and keep liberty under pressure with citizen arms, captains who keep their word, and new laws when the mischiefs are new. Those skills, not a licence to crush, are why the book still answers searches that begin with The Prince.
About Niccolò Machiavelli
Published 1531
Niccolò Machiavelli (1469-1527) served the Florentine Republic as a chancery secretary and diplomat for fourteen years. He wrote dispatches, raised militia, and watched Italian states gain and lose power while France, Spain, and the Church carved the peninsula. When the Medici returned in 1512, he was dismissed, imprisoned, and tortured. He withdrew to a farm outside Florence.
The Prince is the short book from that farm: how a new seat is taken. The Discourses on Livy is the longer one: how a free city is founded, corrupted, and sometimes saved. He reads Roman history as a ledger of republican success and failure, not as patriotic decoration. The commentary was printed in 1531, after his death.
Later republicans across Europe treated it as the other Machiavelli, the one who trusted citizen armies and mixed offices. The nickname "Machiavellian" came from The Prince. This book is why that nickname was always too small.
Why Machiavelli Matters Today
Machiavelli speaks to the moment a city, a company, or a movement still runs on the founder's name: the charter that dies when the chair leaves, the reform that looks new and wrecks the old mix, the peace that is only one order sitting on the other. The Discourses names that pressure from a farm outside Florence after the Medici closed the republican chancery he had served for fourteen years.
What makes him indispensable here is not The Prince. It is the longer commentary that treats Livy as a file of cases. He had raised militia, written dispatches, and watched Florence reformed after Arezzo and ruined after Prato. A city that starts unfree has a ceiling. Tribunes are born from the quarrel of commons and nobles, not from a finished founder. Book III ends on a small ordinance a free city must still write when the mischiefs are new.
Political nicknames are often mistaken for the whole man. Machiavelli is the correction. The Prince taught how a new seat is taken. This book taught how a free city lasts after that man is gone. Readers still search Discourses on Livy versus The Prince because the skills are modern: name the origin, staff offices that outlast the founder, keep quarrel inside the law, time reform so it heals rather than revenges, and write a new ordinance when the mischief is new.
More by Niccolò Machiavelli in Our Library
Wide Reads is different.
Plot, characters, and themes — plus audio, source text, and patterns you can use after class
Two ways in
Read & listen to the summary
Chapter by chapter, with audio. The meaning arrives because you experienced it — not because someone listed bullet points.
Start with this.
Read the original text
The actual words the author wrote, alongside every summary. Use the guide, then step into the source.
Then step into the source.
Either way, the door opens inward.
— and most of all, Why does this matter?
Get the Full Book
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
You Might Also Like
Free to read • No account required




