It is of evil example, especially in the maker of a law, not to observe the law when made. Virginius cites Appius before the people and, when Appius appeals, tells him he is unworthy of the appeal he himself abolished. Appius is dragged to prison and kills himself before trial. A wicked life may deserve every punishment. It is still a bad example, in a republic, to make a law and not keep it, and worst of all when the breaker is the maker. Florence repeats the pattern after 1494. Savonarola fights for an appeal from the Eight and the Signory in state trials, then five citizens are condemned and denied that appeal. In later sermons he neither blames nor excuses the breaker. If the law was salutary he should have caused it to be observed. If useless he should not have promoted it. The ambitious turn of his mind is remarked. Credit falls. Injury that is renewed daily is the other poison. After the Ten fall, accusations keep coming until the nobles believe their whole order will be wiped out. Marcus Duilius the tribune forbids anyone, for a year, to cite or accuse a Roman citizen, and the nobility can breathe. Inflict no injury, or inflict it at a stroke and then let minds settle. Men kept in fear grow daring, and less scrupulous in new courses.
Men climb from one step of ambition to another, seeking first to escape injury and then to injure others. Liberty restored, with new laws, might have meant rest. It does not. Livy writes that whenever one faction is humble, the other grows haughty. The young nobles injure the commons. The tribunes cannot redress. The nobles, though they see the ill behaviour, prefer excesses on their own side. Each faction, seeking to escape fear, makes the other afraid. Caesar in Sallust says that all ill actions have their origin in fair beginnings. The ambitious citizen first gathers friends as if only to be safe, with money or protection that looks honourable. Private citizens begin to fear him. Magistrates treat him with respect. Then it is dangerous to cope with a disorder already advanced: crush him at the risk of immediate ruin, or wait for slavery unless death intervenes. A republic should so order things that a man may acquire influence only as may aid and not injure freedom.
People err in generals and judge in particulars. The commons want the consulship or its restriction. The nobles offer a middle course: four tribunes with consular authority, who may be plebeian or noble. The people, who could choose all from their own order, choose all nobles. Livy notes that after controversy they are governed by a different spirit. In the abstract they had the numbers, the danger, and the valour. In the particular they were ashamed of their own men. After Cannae, Capua is near tumult. Pacuvius Calavius shuts the senate in the palace, tells the people the time has come to trample the nobles, and offers to kill each senator as a substitute is named. The first name draws an uproar against that man's pride. When a substitute from the commons is named, one whistles, another laughs, some jeer. Every name is judged unworthy. Pacuvius says they agree the city would be badly off without a senate, and they are not agreed whom to appoint, so they had better be reconciled. They are. In 1494 Florence, after her greatest citizens are banished, has licence and no regular government. Men hang about the arcades blaming this or that powerful citizen. From time to time one of those speakers rises to the Signory, sees the disorders are the growth of the times, and alters his conduct. Those who heard him as a private man call him cajoled. The proverb is that men had one mind in the marketplace, another in the palace. Eyes open quickly if you can move a crowd from a generality to a named person. In the distribution of honours the people are seldom mistaken.
If you would keep a worthless person out of an office, have it solicited by someone still worse, so the people are ashamed to give, or by someone so distinguished that refusal looks shameful. The Roman senate uses both when it sees the consular tribunes about to be chosen only from the commons. The people then see the particular, not the slogan.