Shared rites can pause a vote, send an army sure of success, and frighten a broken people into standing, and they can be steered. When tribunes with consular powers are almost all plebeians, plague and famine arrive with strange portents. The nobles say the gods are angry at the lowered majesty of government. The people, smitten, choose all the next tribunes from the nobles. At Veii, soldiers clamour to go home until the Alban lake rises and oracles say the city will fall that year. They stay, and Camillus takes it after ten years. Terentillus pushes a law. The nobles search the Sibylline books and return a feigned answer that freedom is at risk through discord that year. The tribunes expose the fraud, and the commons still slacken. Appius Herdonius seizes the Capitol by night with four thousand slaves and outlaws. Publius Rubetius binds the people by oath to the consul. Valerius dies taking the Capitol. Quintius orders them against the Volscians on the same oath, and they obey the dead consul's successor rather than the tribunes. The Terentillian law is parked for a year. Without the rites, Machiavelli says, the senate could not have won that pause.
The same machine is used in war. Armies will not move until the chickens peck. At the battle that breaks the Samnites, the fowls refuse. The chief soothsayer, seeing the army eager, reports the auspices fair. Spurius Papirius tells his uncle the truth. Papirius says the auspices are fair for him and the army. If the soothsayer lied, the lie is on the soothsayer's head. He places the pullarii in front. The chief soothsayer is killed by a Roman spear, and Papirius calls that the army purged of blame. Appius Pulcher, in Sicily, throws the fowls into the sea to see whether they will drink, fights, and is defeated. Rome honours Papirius and condemns Pulcher, not only because one won, but because one kept the show of the rite and the other taught the men it was empty. The object is to send the army in believing it cannot lose.
The Samnites, broken in Etruria, allies gone, still will not submit. Their priest Ovius Paccius revives an ancient sacrifice. Captains swear never to abandon the war. Soldiers swear one by one, ringed by centurions with drawn swords. Those who will not swear are slain. Forty thousand stand near Aquilonia, half in white with plumes. Papirius tells his men that feathers make no wounds, and that such an oath must distract those bound by it, because they have to fear enemies, comrades, and gods at once. They are routed. A rite can frighten men into standing. It cannot restore an army whose fortune is already gone.
Then the argument leaves the field and returns to the people themselves. A people used to living under a prince, if by accident it becomes free, can hardly keep that freedom. Machiavelli likens them to a wild animal reared in a cage: unused to finding its own food, it falls to the first who would recapture it. A newly free state also makes bitter enemies and not warm friends. Those who flourished on the tyrant's wealth want the old ladder back, and those who receive only what merit rules allow will not feel obliged. The remedy is to slay the sons of Brutus, who conspire because the unusual privileges of the kings are withheld under the consuls. Clearchus of Heraclea, caught between nobles and people, puts the nobles to death to satisfy the people's hunger for vengeance, then must still manage their hunger for freedom. France is named as a kingdom whose kings may do as they please with arms and money but are bound by an infinity of laws in everything else. The Romans after the Tarquins can keep freedom because they are not yet corrupt: they kill those sons and close the door. Had they already been corrupt, no remedy in Rome or out of it would have secured them. The body of the people has now been named as the problem.