A man who would reform a free city must keep at least the look of the old ways, even when the new ordinances differ altogether from those they replace. The mass of mankind takes what seems as what is, and is often touched more nearly by appearances than by realities. After the kings are gone, Rome will not give the two consuls more than twelve lictors, so the king's old number of attendants is not exceeded. A yearly sacrifice could be performed only by the king in person. So that the people will not notice a missing rite and desire the throne back, they appoint a priest named Rex sacrificulus, under the chief priest. The solemnity stays. The king does not. If the new magistrates differ in number, authority, or term, they should at least keep the old names. That is the path for anyone founding a constitutional government, commonwealth or limited kingdom.
The tyrant's path is the opposite. A new prince who cannot rest on constitutional government, republic or monarchy, should remake the whole state: new magistracies, new names, new men. Like David he exalts the humble and sends the rich empty away. He pulls down towns, moves inhabitants, and leaves nothing that its possessor can refer to anyone but him. Philip of Macedon, from a petty prince, becomes monarch of all Greece by shifting men from province to province as a shepherd moves flocks. Machiavelli calls these cruel expedients, contrary to every Christian and every civilised rule. Better a private life than a kingship on terms so hurtful. He who will not keep the fair path of virtue must, to maintain himself, enter this path of evil. Most men do neither. They choose middle ways, which of all others are the most pernicious.
In 1505 Julius the Second goes to Bologna to expel the Bentivogli, and also means to remove Giovanpagolo Baglioni, tyrant of Perugia. All men know the intent. The Pope will not wait for a force sufficient for his protection. He enters unattended by troops, though Baglioni has assembled a great company. Urged by his usual impetuosity, with only his bodyguard, he commits himself into the hands of his enemy, carries Baglioni away, and leaves a governor for the Church. Prudent men with the Pope remark on the temerity and on the pusillanimity. Baglioni could have crushed him, plundered the College of Cardinals, and won a deathless fame as the first to teach prelates how little such lives are to be esteemed. It cannot be goodness that withholds him: he lives in incest with his sister and has put nephews and kinsmen to death to obtain the princedom. He cannot, or more truly durst not, complete a crime stamped with greatness. Men who cannot be splendidly wicked or wholly good shrink from that.
Rome, in the histories of republics, shows less ingratitude to great citizens than Athens does, and the cause is not a milder temperament. From the expulsion of the kings down to Sylla and Marius, no citizen subverts Roman liberty, so the city has no grave cause to distrust a man and make him the victim of inconsiderate injustice. Athens, deprived of freedom by Pisistratus under a false show of goodwill, remembers the bondage and becomes the relentless chastiser even of the shadow of an offence: banishment, death, ostracism. A people that has recovered its freedom bites more fiercely than one that has always preserved it. Machiavelli will not condemn Athens or commend Rome as characters. He refers both to necessity. Had Rome been deprived as Athens was, she would not have been more tender. After the kings, Collatinus, though he took part in the liberation, is sent into exile because he bears the name of Tarquin. Publius Valerius almost follows him for building a house on the Caelian hill. Harshness in those two cases is the surmise. The next cluster will ask whether a people or a prince is the more ungrateful, and from which spring the vice comes.