A sudden change of face can unmask you faster than the new hardness can work. Appius's fraud is skilful until he jumps. Pretending goodwill to the commons, forcing his own name onto the second Ten, and stacking colleagues he can trust are all well contrived. Then he turns, in one bound, from friend to enemy, humane to haughty, kind to cruel, and leaves himself no excuse. Everyone sees the two faces. A man who has seemed good and now needs to be bad should change by slow degrees, while the old favour still holds, until he has gained an equal share of new. Jump, and he is unmasked and friendless in the same hour.
Good men spoil cheaply. The youths around Appius sell themselves for trifling benefits drawn from the tyranny. Quintus Fabius, a most worthy man of the second Ten, takes a little ambition and Appius's counsel, abandons his fair fame, and grows like his master. Born good and well brought up is not a safeguard. Laws for a commonwealth must therefore strip people of the hope of doing wrong with impunity.
Under the consuls the Romans win. Under the Ten they lose. The ancient valour has not abated. Goodwill has. An army that fights in its own cause is one thing. An army that fights to satisfy another man's ambition is another. Mercenaries have only a pittance, which cannot make them willing to die. Attachment of that kind is looked for from your own subjects. All who have achieved great things in war have armed the natives of their country. The moment the Ten fall and the soldiers fight as free men, the old spirit returns, and the enterprises close as they used to.
When Virginia dies, the commons withdraw armed to the Sacred Hill. The senate asks by what sanction they have deserted their commanders. They dare not answer. Livy says they were not at a loss for words. They had none to speak for them. A multitude without a head is helpless. Virginius gets them twenty military tribunes. They ask that Valerius and Horatius come. Those two will not come until the Ten lay down office. Then the crowd asks for tribunes of the people, appeal from every magistrate, and the Ten burned alive. The first two demands are granted. The last is refused as the cruelty they condemned in others. Valerius and Horatius tell them to say nothing about the Ten and to regain their own power, since the way to redress will then be open. It is enough to ask another for his weapons. Do not add that you mean to destroy him with them.
Coming Up in Chapter 12
Virginius cites Appius before the people and denies him the appeal he had abolished. Appius kills himself in prison. The new law of appeal is broken on the man who killed it, and Florence will soon break Savonarola's own appeal on five citizens.