Rome does not become a lasting free city because one founder finished the design on day one. Machiavelli will not marvel at her empire until he has asked who founded her and whether she began free. Cities are founded by natives or by strangers. They begin free or under another state's grace. Athens gathers scattered people under Theseus. Venice gathers refugees on islands the barbarians cannot reach by ship. Florence, whether you give it to Sylla's soldiers or to the people of Fiesole coming down to the Arno, starts under Rome and cannot grow past what the sovereign allows. Dinocrates offers Alexander a city carved on Mount Athos in the shape of a man. Alexander asks how the inhabitants will live. The architect has not thought of that. Alexander laughs, leaves the mountain standing, and builds Alexandria where soil, Nile, and sea can feed a people. Fertile land can still make a listless people unless laws enforce the hardship the soil will not. Egypt and the Mamelukes train soldiers against ease. Rome, whether you start it with Aeneas or Romulus, begins in freedom, and the discipline of Romulus, Numa, and the later founders holds for centuries against fertility, sea, and victory. What Rome did at home, by the public voice, is the work of this first part.
A city that begins free still has to choose a form, and the simple forms do not last. Men first follow the strongest, then the most just. Once sovereignty becomes hereditary, princes live for display, are hated, grow afraid, and turn tyrants. The conspicuous men overthrow them and rule as the best, until their descendants, who never had to suffer, convert that government into a government of the few. The multitude then lends itself to anyone who will attack them, refuses to restore the king, and sets up a popular government that slides into licence, where nobody's worth or office is respected. Then they go back to a prince. All six forms are harmful: the three good kinds because they are brief, the three bad because they are bad. A neighbour can swallow the city before the circle even finishes. Wise founders therefore mix king, nobles, and commons so each checks the others. Lycurgus does this on purpose, and Sparta lasts eight hundred years. Solon gives Athens a purely popular government and lives to see Pisistratus. Forty years later Athens recovers her freedom, reverts to the same unmixed form, and lasts only a hundred years more. Florence is the recent proof: reformed in 1502 after Arezzo, ruined in 1512 after Prato. Rome has no Lycurgus. The kings leave good laws, but they founded a kingdom, not a commonwealth. Two consuls keep kingly power without the throne. Senate and consuls are two of the three. The popular share is still missing.
After the Tarquins are driven out, the nobles look united with the commons. The union was fear. While a king could still be called back, they hid their arrogance. Once he is gone, they spit the venom they had kept in their breasts. Men never behave well unless compelled. As hunger makes them industrious, laws make them good. Tribunes are created, after much uproar, and given station enough to stand between the people and the senate.
Those who call Rome turbulent, Machiavelli says, condemn the cause of her becoming free. They stare at the noise and miss the laws. From the Tarquins to the Gracchi, more than three hundred years, tumult rarely means exile or blood: eight or ten citizens banished, very few put to death. Shops close. The people refuse enrolment as soldiers until something of their demands is conceded. Laws favourable to freedom come out of that noise. Those magistrates, he says, also acted as the guardians of Roman freedom. Who should hold those keys is not yet argued.