A new constitution must be the work of one man, but the act is excused only if the morning after produces shared offices and rites, not a personal throne. Romulus kills Remus and later consents to the death of Titus Tatius, his Sabine colleague. The act would condemn the doer if the end were private ambition. He is excused because he at once creates a senate, takes counsel with it, and keeps almost nothing but the command of the army when war is resolved and the right to assemble that senate. The multitude cannot agree on the first design. Once taught, they will not abandon it. Absolute authority must not pass as an inheritance. Agis tries to bring Sparta back to Lycurgus and the Ephori have him strangled as a would-be tyrant. Cleomenes reads Agis's notes, stands alone, kills the Ephori, renews the laws, and still falls to the Macedonians because he has no partner while the reform is unfinished. The founder must stand alone. The tyrant must not hide behind that rule.
Praise falls first on founders of religions, then of kingdoms and commonwealths, then on captains, then on men of letters. Founders of tyranny sit on the other side of the ledger. Private citizens should prefer Scipio to Caesar. Rulers should prefer Agesilaus, Timoleon, and Dion to Nabis, Phalaris, and Dionysius. Those who praise Caesar have been overawed by the empire governed in his name. Historians who cannot blame him blame Catiline and praise Brutus instead. Of twenty-six emperors from Caesar to Maximinus, sixteen die by violence and ten by a natural death. Titus, Nerva, Trajan, Hadrian, Antoninus, and Marcus need no praetorian cohorts. Caligula, Nero, and Vitellius are not saved by the armies of east and west. All who succeed by birth except Titus are bad. All who succeed by adoption from Nerva to Marcus are good. In their years the senate keeps its authority, rank and merit are respected, and a man may hold the opinions he pleases. In the other years Italy is overwhelmed, Rome is burned, the ceremonies of religion are corrupted, and informers are rewarded. The prince who can give a constitution and still keep sovereignty has no excuse if he chooses Caesar's path over Romulus's.
Rome's second founder is Numa. The senate chooses him because Romulus's institutions are not enough for so great a state. He finds a fierce people and calls in religion as essential to civil society, so that for many ages God is nowhere so much feared as in that republic. After Cannae, Scipio makes citizens swear not to abandon Italy, and they stay though love of country had not held them. Titus Manlius forces the tribune Marcus Pomponius to swear he will drop a charge against Lucius Manlius, and the tribune keeps the oath. Had the debt to be weighed, Machiavelli would give Numa more than Romulus: arms can follow religion, religion does not easily follow arms. Numa feigns intercourse with a nymph because unusual laws will not be accepted on reason alone. Lycurgus and Solon do the same. Savonarola persuades Florence, which does not think itself rude, that he spoke with God. A kingdom that rests only on a prince's fear lasts as long as that prince.
Princes and commonwealths that would stay uncorrupted must keep the rites uncorrupted. The surest sign of decay is contempt for divine worship. Gentile religion rested on oracles. When those oracles shaped answers to suit powerful men, the multitude grew incredulous. At Veii, soldiers ask Juno's statue whether she will come to Rome, and Camillus confirms the yes they think they hear. Machiavelli's two proofs against the claim that Italy is made safe by the Church of Rome are these: those who live nearest that court are less devout than any others, and dependence on that court has kept the peninsula divided, never strong enough to unite it and never too weak to call in a foreign prince. Carry that court into the Swiss territories, he says, and its manners would do more mischief there than any other disaster. The Swiss, in religion and in arms, still live like the ancients. Italy has the head of the faith and not the discipline. How those rites are used in the senate and in the field is not yet shown.