Freedom handed to a corrupt people will not stay, no matter how loudly the palace changes its name. If the Tarquins had stayed two or three reigns longer, the taint would have moved from the head to the members, and Rome would have been past cure. They are expelled while the trunk is still sound, so liberty can be seized and kept. After Caesar, Caligula, and Nero, when the Julian line is extinct, Rome cannot even venture a step toward freedom. The same city, two different bodies of people. An oath against kings was enough the first time. Later, Brutus with all the legions of the East cannot rouse them, because the Marian faction, with Caesar at its head, has blinded the multitude. Dion and Timoleon keep Syracuse free only while they live. Naples and Milan, Machiavelli says, could not be restored to a free government by any change, however grave, because the entire people has grown corrupt. Milan after Filippo Visconti has neither force nor skill to keep a free form. Thebes falls when Epaminondas dies. Inequality of that kind is not fixed by a new title on the palace.
A corrupt city is also hard to keep free if it already has free forms. Good customs need good laws, and laws need good customs. Rome alters particular laws as men grow worse, and leaves the institutions standing: people, senate, tribunes, consuls, the methods of choosing magistrates, the way laws are passed. Those institutions, unchanged, then corrupt the new laws. At first, only the worthy seek the consulship, and to be rejected is disgrace. After Africa, Asia, and nearly all Greece are reduced, security teaches the people to confer office by favour, then by influence, until good men are wholly excluded. Open debate on laws, which was a virtue when citizens were good, becomes a tool. Only the powerful propose. None dare speak against them. The people vote their own destruction. Gradual reform needs a sagacious man who can see mischief in the germ, and who can persuade others. Sudden reform needs violence and a prince, which asks a good man to use bad means, or a bad man to use power well. Cleomenes and Romulus could use extraordinary means because they were not dealing with this degree of rot. For a city this corrupt, Machiavelli would rather a nearly absolute monarchy than a popular form that cannot restrain the arrogant.
Then the argument turns from the people to the sequence of princes. After a strong prince a weak one may hold the seat. After two weak princes a kingdom falls, unless ancient ordinances hold it, as in France. Rome is lucky in her first kings: Romulus fierce, Numa peaceful and religious, Tullus warlike again, Ancus able to use both until neighbours take him for effeminate and he returns to arms. David leaves Solomon a tranquil state. Rehoboam keeps a sixth of the kingdom. Bajazet enjoys Muhammad's conquests. Had Selim been like Bajazet and not like his grandfather, the Turkish monarchy would have been overthrown. A prince like Numa holds or loses as fortune befriends him. A prince like Romulus, fortified with foresight and arms, holds whatever befalls unless an irresistible force takes the state. While Rome lives under kings, it is in constant danger of a weak or bad one.
Once the kings are gone, consuls take authority by the free suffrages of their fellow-citizens, not by inheritance, craft, or violence, and they are always men of signal worth. Rome reaches the height of her greatness in as many years as she had lived under kings. Philip and Alexander, two valiant princes in a row, can conquer the world. A well-ordered commonwealth can choose not two such men, but an endless succession. The machine is named. The men who would fill it have not yet been taught to fight.