Liberty lasts when the people who want not to be dominated hold the keys, and when anger has a lawful charge instead of a rumour. Wise founders, Machiavelli says, must create a guardianship of freedom. Put it in the wrong hands and the free city does not last. In every republic the nobles want to dominate and the commons want not to be dominated. Sparta and Venice give the keys to nobles and keep liberty longer. Rome gives them to the commons. He would rather the commons guard it, because they have less to gain by destroying it. The other side has a case. Tribunes, once armed, demand both consulships, then the censorship and praetorship, and later pay court to men who can attack the nobility, which opens the road to Marius. When Marcus Menenius is made dictator to look into Capuan plots and into corrupt honours at home, the nobles turn the inquiry on him. He lays down the office, is acquitted, and the hearing still cannot settle whether those who would acquire power or those who would keep it are more dangerous. Machiavelli's rule is that the fear of loss in those who already hold power breeds the same passions as hunger in those who have nothing.
Some regret that Rome could not do great things without being torn until the Gracchi. Machiavelli asks whether a quieter constitution was even available. Venice closes civil rights once her first settlers have enough numbers, names them Gentlemen, and never employs later arrivals in affairs that would make them important. Sparta keeps few inhabitants, shuts foreigners out, and lets kings for life stand between nobles and commons so the people neither fear nor covet offices they do not hold. To copy that quiet, Rome would have had to keep the commons out of war, or close the city to strangers. She does the opposite: she arms them and multiplies them. Remove the causes of her tumults and you also remove the causes of her growth. A numerous, warlike people who can win an empire cannot afterwards be governed at pleasure. A few unwarlike people who are easy to govern cannot hold what they take. A founder who wants only to last might copy Sparta or Venice, fortify a strong site, and forbid extension. Machiavelli does not believe that equilibrium can be kept. All human affairs are in movement. A city that will not enlarge grows listless and divided. A city that enlarges on weak foundations falls. Sparta, after nearly all Greece, falls when Thebes revolts under Pelopidas. Venice, after buying much of Italy, loses it in one pitched battle. There is no middle way. If you want Roman greatness, you put up with the quarrel between commons and senate.
The useful power of those guardians is the right to accuse. A citizen who has offended against the liberty of the country can be brought before the people or a tribunal. Fear of that charge checks attempts. A lawful vent lets the crowd's anger out instead of a knife. Coriolanus advises the senate to starve the commons by withholding Sicilian corn. The people would have slain him leaving the senate house if the tribunes had not cited him to answer a formal charge. Had they killed him there, fear would have sought defence, defence faction, and faction the ruin of the state. Florence cannot do this. Francesco Valori, once the foremost citizen, is treated as ambitious, and there is no lawful form in which to oppose him, so both sides raise factions and come to open violence. Piero Soderini falls because eight judges are not enough to try a powerful man, and the people call in a Spanish army. Rome, with a remedy at home, never seeks one abroad. Aruns, denied redress at Clusium after a Lucumo violates his sister, invites the Gauls. If the law had heard him, the barbarians would not have been asked.
Calumny is the counterfeit of that charge. Manlius Capitolinus cannot bear the glory given to Camillus after the Gauls. He hints that treasure meant for them has been embezzled, then will not name who holds it. The dictator cites him before the whole city. He answers evasively. He is sent to prison. Impeachment needs a named offence and evidence, and it happens before magistrates. Calumny needs neither, and it happens in the streets. Florence lets rumour run. Giovanni Guicciardini is said to have been bribed at Lucca, cannot give himself up to the captain of justice because the laws allow no such clearing, and the quarrel helps bring the republic down. Rome's rule is simpler: force the whisperer to become an accuser. True, and he is not punished. False, and he is punished as Manlius was. The charge sheet can keep the quarrel inside the city. It does not yet say who is allowed to write the first laws.