A law that reaches backward against old usage can split a city faster than the abuse it names. Men remain dissatisfied because they want everything and cannot have it. In Rome that hunger, after the tribunes already exist, becomes a contest for honours and wealth, and takes the form of land. The agrarian law has two blows: no citizen may hold more than a fixed number of acres, and all land taken from the enemy is to be shared among the whole people. Both hit the nobles. The law is never named without convulsing the city. It may have been badly framed, postponed until its backward reach made tumult, or perverted in use. The nobles temporize: they call out the army, set tribune against tribune, or send a colony to Antium, where Livy notes that almost no Roman will go, so much readier are the commons to covet at home than to leave. When Roman arms go far, enemy fields are too remote to farm, and the hunger sleeps. It wakes in the Gracchi, whose motives Machiavelli would rather praise than their measures. Factions then set up chiefs. The commons make Marius consul four times, then three more. The nobles set Sylla against him. Later Caesar heads the Marian party and Pompey Sylla's. Caesar is the first tyrant in Rome. After him the city is never again free. The three-hundred-year quarrel still restrained the nobles. Without it, slavery would have come sooner. Wealth is defended more stubbornly than honours. To pass a law against ancient usage, with stringent retrospective effect, in order to pull up a long abuse, is to hurry the mischief. If you temporize, the abuse may grow more slowly, or die before it comes to a head.
Weak republics do not choose. They wait. A pestilence in Rome looks to the Equians and Volscians like a chance to crush her. The Latins and Hernicians ask for defence. The senate, which has forbidden them to arm themselves on other days, now tells them to look to their own forces, and to do it with leave, lest men driven to disobey by necessity come afterwards to disobey from choice. Florence will not follow that method. Duke Valentino, after Faenza, asks to pass through Tuscany with a strong army. The council refuses leave, though they cannot stop him, and so he passes in spite of them instead of with their consent. In 1500 Louis has Milan again and sends Beaumont to put Pisa back in Florentine hands for fifty thousand ducats. The Pisans offer to surrender to the French if the king will not hand them to Florence for four months. Florence rejects the terms, distrusts the king it must still pay, and the siege fails. In 1502 Arezzo revolts. Imbalt takes the settlement into his own hands, enters, and tells the Florentines they are fools: the king can give them the town more easily with his soldiers inside than outside. They abuse him until they see that if Beaumont had done the same they would have had Pisa as well as Arezzo. Irresolute republics, unless a stronger force shoves them, never take the wise course. Wherever there is room for doubt, weakness will not let them resolve. They remain in suspense.
The same desires and passions prevail in all cities as they always have. A man who reads the past can foresee the next accident, or invent a remedy the ancients would have used. In 1494 Florence loses Pisa and other towns, spends heavily, and hates the Ten of the War as if they were the disease. The people let the magistracy lapse, put affairs on the Signory, and lose Arezzo besides. Then they see the evil was in the disease and not in the physician, and restore the Ten. Rome does the same with the consular name. The people ascribe endless wars to the nobles' wish to crush them outside the city, under consuls, where tribunes cannot help. Terentillus proposes a committee of five to regulate consular power. The tribunes abolish the consular title and put tribunes with consular powers in their room, so much greater is the hatred of the name than of the thing. After a long time the commons discover the mistake and resume consuls, as Florence resumed the Ten.
The Decemvirate shows how the same causes can save or ruin. After wrangling over new laws, Spurius Posthumius and two others go to Athens for Solon's code. Ten men, among them Appius Claudius, are appointed for a year. Consulate, tribuneship, and appeal are suspended so they may act without fear. Appius, once thought a persecutor of the people, turns conciliatory. They write ten tables, expose them, and Appius then says two more tables are needed, hoping for a second year. The people consent, to keep consuls out and because they think they can hold ground without tribunes. On the reappointment the nobles canvass. Appius displays such cordiality that they put him forward, the youngest, to name the Ten, thinking he will not name himself. He names himself first, then nine he can trust. He throws off the mask, infects his colleagues, and they appoint one hundred and twenty lictors instead of twelve. They prolong the office by force when the year ends, gathering young nobles enriched with condemned men's goods. War with Sabines and Volscians forces them to assemble the senate. Valerius and Horatius inveigh. The senate, jealous, will not cut the Ten short, fearing that if they lay down office the tribunes may not return. They send armies under some of the Ten. Appius stays in the city, becomes enamoured of Virginia, and drives her father to kill her. Soldiers and commons go to the Sacred Hill until the Ten lay down. Both parties emptied every other office because each wanted to abolish the other's magistrates, and so created a tyranny by votes. Appius then takes the opposite course from every successful tyrant: he makes himself obnoxious to the people who were conferring the power, and seeks friendship from nobles who can never all be satisfied. Nabis of Sparta holds by the people. Appius cannot arm a peasantry distinct from the people, and is ruined at the outset. King Ferrando's small birds stay intent on the prey and do not see the eagle overhead.