A people will take a course that looks profitable or spirited even when the country's death sits behind it, and will refuse a course that looks base even when safety is bound up with it. When Veii falls, half of Rome wants to move there: the city is well built, the country fertile, the distance short, and civil affairs, they say, will not be affected. The senate and the wiser citizens would rather die than consent. The commons grow so inflamed that bloodshed is near, until old and esteemed men are put forward and respect stops the violence. Unless someone they still trust can turn them, they labour for their own ruin. If they have been deceived before and trust no one, the ruin is inevitable. Fabius cannot make them wait against Hannibal, because waiting looks like disgrace. They make Varro consul because he promises, in the streets, to make an end of Hannibal. Cannae follows. Penula, a man of mean origin, offers to take Hannibal with volunteers. The senate knows it is rash and grants it anyway, rather than face the people's anger. He and his rabble die in the first encounter. Nicias cannot stop Athens from Sicily. Scipio, denied Africa, threatens to take the question to the people. Florence invests Pisa on Ercole Bentivoglio's brave promises. Giacomini, failing to take it, loses all his past services in one day. There is no readier way to ruin a republic, when the people have the power, than to suggest daring courses.
The same Veii passage shows how to stop a crowd. Virgil's reverend chief appears and they wait. Francesco Soderini, bishop of Volterra, puts on his best apparel and episcopal robes, walks out to an armed mob at his brother's house, and by words and mien brings them to a stay. A commander or a governor, when tumult has broken out, should assume the noblest bearing he can and clothe himself with the ensigns of his station. There is no surer restraint on an unruly multitude than the presence of someone whose character and bearing command respect.
Government is easy where the body of the people is not corrupted, and a princedom is impossible where equality prevails. The senate trusts Romans to declare a tenth of Veii's spoil for Apollo. They do not think of giving less in secret. They think of showing their displeasure in public. German free states let each man swear and throw into a chest what he believes he owes, with no witness but himself. The impost still yields what it was estimated to yield. That virtue survives, Machiavelli says, because they mix little with neighbours and will not suffer gentlemen: idle men living on the revenues of estates, worse still lords of strongholds with vassals. Naples, the country round Rome, Romagna, and Lombardy are full of them, and have never been free. Tuscany has equality enough for a commonwealth: Florence, Lucca, and Siena have long existed as republics in a narrow compass, and the other Tuscan cities still show by their spirit that they preserve, or desire to preserve, their freedom, because there are no lords of strongholds and few gentlemen. Up to the present hour that country has never produced the man with the power and knowledge to found on that equality. He who would found a commonwealth where there are many gentlemen must first get rid of them. He who would found a princedom where equality prevails must raise restless men into real lords, with castles and retainers. The Venetian seeming exception is a title of honour: they draw no great revenues from lands, possess no castle, and enjoy no feudal authority. In that city gentleman and plebeian name who may hold honour, and the split occasions no disturbance. Constitute a republic where equality is, a princedom where it is not. Otherwise what is constituted is discordant, and without stability.
Then a fact he will not explain. No great calamity arrives without a sign. Savonarola foretells Charles VIII. Horsemen fight in the air over Arezzo. Lightning strikes the cathedral before Lorenzo dies, and the palace before Soderini falls. A voice on the Via Nova warns that the Gauls are coming. After the warnings, the disasters come. Whether the air is filled with intelligent beings who take pity, he does not know. What to do with the signs is not given.