A city without its own army is not short of men. It is short of a ruler who knows how to make subjects into soldiers. Tullus inherits Rome after forty years of peace and cannot find a single man who has ever been in battle, yet he does not hire the Samnites or the Etruscans. He trains his own countrymen, and they become admirable soldiers. An English king, after thirty years of peace, invades France with men who have never looked an enemy in the face, because his kingdom never relaxes warlike discipline in peacetime. Pelopidas and Epaminondas arm an effeminate Thebes and beat Sparta. Warriors are not bred in Lacedaemon alone. Virgil's Tullus rouses sluggish warriors. Shame here is a training failure.
Then two kings agree that the nation whose three champions win shall rule the other. The Alban Curiatii die. One Roman Horatius lives. Alba becomes subject. On the road home Horatius meets his sister, wife to a dead Curiatius, weeping, and kills her. He is tried and freed more on his father's entreaties than on his deserts. Machiavelli marks three notes, and the first two wait for the next movements. The third is already visible: a covenant that enslaves a people because three men fell will not be kept. Metius confesses himself vanquished, then on the joint march to Veii tries to circumvent Tullus, as if he had seen too late how rash the stake was.
The rashness is to peril a whole fortune where you do not put forth your whole strength. Tullus and Metius left the power to ruin two cities in six soldiers, and so made futile all the labour of their predecessors in framing institutions that the citizens themselves might have kept free. Guarding a defile often repeats that error. Unless almost the whole army can sit in the pass, holding it is hurtful: the attacker means to move through, the defender may have to lodge in a sterile tract for a long time, and if the pass falls the rest of the army panics without ever fighting. Hannibal crosses the Alps; the Romans wait on the Ticino and on the plain of Arezzo, preferring a chance of victory on open ground to destruction in mountain fastnesses. Capable commanders rarely try to close every pass, because mountains, like plains, have byways known to the country. In 1515 Francis the First of France, invading to recover Lombardy, leaves two or three Swiss-guarded defiles aside, takes an unknown way, and is in Italy before his enemies know. They flee into Milan. Lombardy, cheated of the mountain delay it had trusted, goes over to the French.
Rome still tries Horatius. His valour against the Curiatii deserved the highest reward. Slaying his sister was a separate crime. A well-ordered state never strikes a balance between services and misdeeds: it pays the one, then chastises the other, without regard to former deserts. Mix the ledgers and a saviour becomes too arrogant for civil bonds. Small gifts still honour great service when the city is poor: two ploughgates for Horatius Cocles and for Mucius Scaevola; a measure of meal from each person shut in the Capitol for Manlius. Later Manlius, jealous, tries to raise sedition. The people throw him from that same Capitol without regard to the old renown. Past service does not buy a later crime. How a free city can change its ordinances without looking as if it has changed them is not yet asked.