Chapter 24
When Government Gives Money Back
OF DRAWBACKS. Merchants and manufacturers are not contented with the monopoly of the home market, but desire likewise the most extensive foreign sale for their goods. Their country has no jurisdiction in foreign nations, and therefore can seldom procure them any monopoly there. They are generally obliged, therefore, to content themselves with petitioning for certain encouragements to exportation. Of these encouragements, what are called drawbacks seem to be the most reasonable. To allow the merchant to draw back upon exportation, either the whole, or a part of whatever excise or inland duty is imposed upon domestic industry, can never occasion…
Public-domain chapter text, formatted for reading.
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"To allow the merchant to draw back upon exportation, either the whole, or a part of whatever excise or inland duty is imposed upon domestic industry, can never occasion the exportation of a greater quantity of goods than what would have been exported had no duty been imposed."
Context: Why drawbacks on domestic goods are reasonable
Refunds remove export penalties without creating artificial volume.
In Today's Words:
Refunding excise taxes when goods are exported does not create extra exports beyond what the market already wanted. It simply stops domestic taxes from punishing exporters who would have sold abroad anyway. Smith treats drawbacks as restoring neutrality, not as a subsidy that bends trade toward favored industries.
"They tend not to overturn that balance which naturally establishes itself among all the various employments of the society, but to hinder it from being overturned by the duty."
Context: Drawbacks preserve natural employment of capital
Good drawback policy blocks distortion rather than steering investment.
In Today's Words:
Well-designed duty refunds do not pick winning industries or swell one trade beyond its natural size. They stop a tax from pushing capital away from its ordinary uses. Smith argues the goal is to leave the balance of employments intact, not to redirect resources through export incentives paid from the treasury.
"We are unwilling even to be the carriers of French goods, and choose rather to forego a profit to ourselves than to suffer those whom we consider as our enemies to make any profit by our means."
Context: Retained duties on re-exported French goods
National animosity overrides merchant profit on carrying trade.
In Today's Words:
Britain kept punitive duties even when re-exporting French goods because national animosity toward France mattered more than merchant profit. Smith shows how drawback rules encode politics: traders may forgo carrying trade, yet legislators prefer that loss to letting rivals profit through British shipping and ports.
"Drawbacks, however, it must always be understood, are useful only in those cases in which the goods, for the exportation of which they are given, are really exported to some foreign country, and not clandestinely re-imported into our own."
Context: Closing warning on tobacco fraud
Refunds require genuine export or they become revenue fraud.
In Today's Words:
Duty refunds work only when goods actually leave for another country. If merchants claim export while smuggling goods back home, drawbacks become theft from the treasury and unfair competition. Smith closes by noting tobacco drawbacks were often abused this way, hurting honest traders and public revenue alike.
Thematic Threads
Power
In This Chapter
Government officials use trade policy to reward political allies and punish enemies, regardless of economic merit
Development
Expanding from individual merchant power to institutional political power
In Your Life:
You might see this when workplace policies somehow never apply equally to management favorites
Corruption
In This Chapter
The drawback system invites fraud as people claim refunds for exports that never actually left the country
Development
Introduced here as systematic rather than individual corruption
In Your Life:
You might see this in insurance claims, expense reports, or any system based on self-reporting
Class
In This Chapter
Colonial merchants get special trade deals unavailable to others, creating privileged economic classes
Development
Continuing theme of how economic systems create and maintain class divisions
In Your Life:
You might see this in how certain neighborhoods get better city services or schools
Identity
In This Chapter
French goods get worse treatment because France is considered an enemy, showing how national identity overrides economic logic
Development
Expanding from personal identity to group identity affecting economic decisions
In Your Life:
You might see this in hiring bias or how your background affects the opportunities offered to you
Manipulation
In This Chapter
Politicians disguise favoritism as economic policy, making special deals look like general principles
Development
Introduced here as institutional manipulation rather than personal
In Your Life:
You might see this when company 'restructuring' somehow benefits certain departments while claiming to be fair
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
This is not a test. Five prompts guide you through the chapter, from how it opens to how it closes, so you notice context and rhythm rather than facts to memorize. Sit with each question in your own words. When you see "One way to read it," treat it as a starting point, not the only answer.
- 1
Why do drawbacks on domestic excise not increase exports beyond the natural level?
analysis • surfaceOne way to read it
They refund taxes that would otherwise penalize exporters, restoring the quantity that would have been sent abroad without the duty. They do not add new capital or force extra production, only prevent the tax from diverting it.
- 2
Why does Smith allow full drawbacks on colonial tobacco but deny them on warehoused French silks?
analysis • mediumOne way to read it
Tobacco surpluses needed re-export to clear monopoly imports, while jealous manufacturers feared warehoused foreign goods would leak into the home market and compete with protected domestic producers.
- 3
How can customs revenue profit from drawbacks even when part of the duty is refunded?
application • mediumOne way to read it
Without drawbacks, high duties would block re-export and often prevent import altogether for want of a market. The portion of duty retained on goods that do circulate through export trade would otherwise never be collected.
- 4
Why are drawbacks to American colonies often pure loss to the revenue?
application • deepOne way to read it
Colonial monopoly means the same quantity might be sent even if duties were fully retained, so the refund does not enlarge trade. It simply transfers tax revenue to merchants who already control the protected market.
- 5
What abuse of tobacco drawbacks does Smith warn against at the chapter's close?
reflection • deepOne way to read it
Merchants claim export refunds while clandestinely re-importing goods into Britain, defrauding customs and undercutting fair traders. Drawbacks are justified only when goods truly reach foreign countries.
Critical Thinking Exercise
Track the Corruption Drift
Choose a rule or policy in your life that feels unfair now - at work, in your family, or in your community. Write down what you think the original purpose was, then list all the exceptions and special cases that have been added over time. Finally, identify who benefits most from the current version versus the original intent.
Consider:
- •Look for patterns where 'temporary' exceptions became permanent advantages
- •Notice who has the power to create or ignore exceptions
- •Consider whether the original problem still exists or if new problems have been created
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you saw a fair system gradually become unfair through small compromises. How did you respond, and what would you do differently now that you recognize this pattern?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 25: Government Handouts and Market Manipulation
Smith next examines bounties, direct payments to exporters that go beyond refunding duties, asking whether such subsidies enlarge national industry or distort capital toward trades that cannot sustain themselves without perpetual expense from the public purse.
