Chapter 15
Me or Luzhin
PART III CHAPTER I Raskolnikov got up, and sat down on the sofa. He waved his hand weakly to Razumihin to cut short the flow of warm and incoherent consolations he was addressing to his mother and sister, took them both by the hand and for a minute or two gazed from one to the other without speaking. His mother was alarmed by his expression. It revealed an emotion agonisingly poignant, and at the same time something immovable, almost insane. Pulcheria Alexandrovna began to cry. Avdotya Romanovna was pale; her hand trembled in her brother’s. “Go home... with him,” he…
Public-domain chapter text, formatted for reading.
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"at the first opportunity to-morrow you must refuse Luzhin"
Context: Ordering Dunya to break the engagement tomorrow
First family act after the murders. He cannot confess but can veto Luzhin.
In Today's Words:
He tells his sister to refuse the fiancé at the first chance tomorrow and never speak his name again. That is control without explanation. When you cannot tell the whole truth, you still draw lines around what family must not do. Marriage here is the line.
"It’s me or Luzhin! Go now"
Context: Ultimatum before turning to the wall
Brother versus benefactor. Despotism born of fear and love mixed.
In Today's Words:
He says it is him or the fiancé, then orders them out of the room. Harsh and desperate. He is not offering a fair choice; he is forcing loyalty while hiding the reason. Families hear that tone when someone is protecting them and hurting them at once without saying why.
"go wrong in one’s own way is better than"
Context: Drunk on the pavement after escorting the ladies
Philosophy of integrity over convenience. Contrasts Luzhin's self-interest sermon.
In Today's Words:
His drunk friend says it is better to fail on your own path than succeed on someone else's. That is the novel's answer to utilitarian marriage and career. Wrong in your own way still leaves you a person; right in another's way makes you a tool.
"tell you, your _fiancé_ is a scoundrel"
Context: To Pulcheria and Dunya on the street
Protective insult. He has seen Luzhin's lodgings and Raskolnikov's revulsion; he speaks without tact but with truth.
In Today's Words:
The friend blurts that the fiancé is a scoundrel while walking the mother and sister home in the dark. Socially outrageous, emotionally accurate. Sometimes the person with no polish says what the family was trained not to hear. His drunken honesty speeds the break Raskolnikov demanded at the bedside.
Thematic Threads
Family
In This Chapter
Bedside reunion after faint
Development
Love and terror mixed; orders replace affection
Marriage
In This Chapter
Refuse Luzhin; infamy
Development
Central conflict of Part III opening
Sacrifice
In This Chapter
Dunya's engagement versus brother
Development
Raskolnikov blocks her sacrifice without explaining
Razumihin's love
In This Chapter
Escort, scoundrel speech, jealousy
Development
Introduced as protector and suitor in waiting
Monomania
In This Chapter
Zossimov's diagnosis
Development
Medical near-miss on murder fixation
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
This is not a test. Five prompts guide you through the chapter, from how it opens to how it closes, so you notice context and rhythm rather than facts to memorize. Sit with each question in your own words. When you see "One way to read it," treat it as a starting point, not the only answer.
- 1
What does Raskolnikov demand of Dunya when he wakes to find mother and sister at his bedside?
analysis • surfaceOne way to read it
He forbids the marriage to Luzhin at the first chance, calling it infamy and declaring it is me or Luzhin. He will play the scoundrel if needed, but they must not sell Dunya for his sake.
- 2
On the stairs Razumihin warns the ladies about Rodya's delirious outing and Luzhin's lodgings. What role does he take?
analysis • mediumOne way to read it
He becomes protector and nurse without asking forgiveness for his drunken abuse of Luzhin. He filters danger for Pulcheria and Dunya while hiding how far Rodya has already gone morally.
- 3
Razumihin says people go wrong in their own way and calls the fiancé a windbag. How does his loyalty compare to Rodya's ultimatum?
application • mediumOne way to read it
Both men oppose Luzhin, but Razumihin offers steady care while Rodya delivers violent commands from a sickbed. One builds a household; the other tries to control it with shame and refusal.
- 4
Zossimov tells the family Rodya needs rest and a favorable shock. Why is medical language inadequate here?
analysis • deepOne way to read it
Fever and monomania are real, yet the illness is also moral and legal. Treating him as a patient avoids the murder, the confession to Zametov, and the money spent on Marmeladov.
- 5
Razumihin and Zossimov argue about who understands Rodya. What tension does that create for the family downstairs?
reflection • deepOne way to read it
The women must trust men who disagree on the diagnosis while neither names the worst possibility. Their reunion is framed by male interpreters, so Dunya's agency stays inside a plot she has not fully seen.
Critical Thinking Exercise
When to Say No to the Match
Identify a time a relative faced a commitment that felt exploitative (partner, job, loan, landlord). Write what you could oppose without full disclosure, who could speak for you, and what harm blocking it might prevent. Compare Raskolnikov's refuse Luzhin order and Razumihin's scoundrel speech.
Consider:
- •Separate protecting someone from controlling them
- •Notice who carries truth when the patient cannot
- •Ask what tomorrow's confrontation will cost the silent person
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 16: Luzhin's Letter
In the morning Razumihin will wake ashamed, Luzhin's letter will arrive about Marmeladov's money, and the family will meet Raskolnikov at ten with the engagement still unresolved.
