Ivan Ilyich can name death, hear that his sufferings have no reason, and still smile as if the correctness of his life were an explanation. A fortnight on, he no longer leaves the sofa. He will not lie in bed. He lies facing the wall nearly all the time, and in that loneliness asks the same insoluble question: what is this, can it be death? The inner voice answers yes, it is death. Why these sufferings? For no reason, they just are so. Beyond that there is nothing. From the first doctor's visit his mind has swung between two moods: despair at a death he cannot understand, and hope, when he watches a kidney or an intestine as if it had only evaded its duty. The further the illness goes, the more fantastic the kidney becomes, and the more real the death. He has only to remember what he was three months ago, and how regularly he has gone downhill, and every possibility of hope is shattered.
He is lonely in a populous town, surrounded by acquaintances and relations, as lonely as if he lay at the bottom of the sea or under the earth. Pictures of the past rise and always run backwards from what is nearest to childhood, and rest there. Stewed prunes offered that day become the raw shrivelled French plums of childhood, then his nurse, his brother, their toys. No, he must not think of that. It is too painful. He brings himself back to the button on the sofa and the creases in its morocco, and even that quarrel about expensive leather opens another: father's torn portfolio, punishment, and mamma bringing tarts. Childhood returns, hurts, and he tries to banish it. Then another series runs with the first: how the illness grew worse. The further back he looks, the more life there had been. The two merge. Just as the pain got worse and worse, so his life grew worse and worse. One bright spot at the beginning, then blacker and blacker, faster and faster, in inverse ratio to the square of the distance from death. A stone falling downwards with increasing velocity. I am flying.
He shudders, shifts, tries to resist, and already knows resistance is impossible. He stares at the back of the sofa and waits for the fall, the shock, the destruction. If he could only understand what it is all for. An explanation would be possible if it could be said that he has not lived as he ought. He remembers all the legality, correctitude, and propriety of his life. That at any rate cannot be admitted. His lips smile ironically, as if someone could see that smile and be taken in by it. There is no explanation. Agony, death. What for?
Coming Up in Chapter 11
Two weeks later Petrishchev formally proposes, the match Ivan and his wife had wanted. But the next morning Ivan has changed for the worse. When his wife starts on his medicines, he turns such a look on her that she stops, and he begs her to let him die in peace.