The thought that had appeared perfectly impossible now holds: Ivan's whole life may have been wrong. Once it holds, every familiar face becomes proof, and even a sacrament cannot survive one polite question. Two weeks on, Petrishchev formally proposes, the match Ivan and his wife had wanted. That night Ivan changes for the worse. In the morning Praskovya Fedorovna comes in considering how to tell him, and finds him on his back, groaning, staring straight ahead. She begins on his medicines. He turns on her such a look of animosity that she stops, and he asks to be left to die in peace. Lisa comes to say good morning. He looks at her as he looked at his wife, and says he will soon free them all of himself. They sit, then leave. Lisa asks her mother if it is their fault, why they should be tortured. The doctor comes at his usual time. Ivan answers yes and no, never taking his angry eyes off him, then tells him he can do nothing, so leave him alone. Opium is the only resource left.
Worse than the pain is the thought that came in the night, as he looked at Gerasim's sleepy, good-natured face: what if my whole life has been wrong? The scarcely perceptible impulses he once suppressed, against what the most highly placed people called good, may have been the real thing, and his professional duties, his family, his social and official interests the false part. He tries to defend them and feels the weakness of what he is defending. There is nothing to defend. If he is leaving this life knowing he has lost all that was given him, and it is impossible to put right, what then? In the morning he sees first his footman, then his wife, then his daughter, then the doctor. Their every word and movement confirm the truth of the night. In them he sees himself, all that he had lived for, and sees that it was not real, but a terrible and huge deception that had hidden both life and death. The seeing intensifies his physical suffering tenfold. He groans, tosses, pulls at clothing that chokes him, and hates them on that account.
At noon the opium wears off and he drives everybody away. Praskovya comes and asks him to take communion, as healthy people often do. It is unnecessary, he says, then agrees. The priest hears his confession. Ivan is softened, feels a relief from his doubts, and for a moment a ray of hope. He thinks again of the vermiform appendix and the possibility of correcting it. He receives the sacrament with tears in his eyes. Laid down afterwards, he feels a moment's ease, and the hope that he might live wakes: to live, I want to live. His wife comes in to congratulate him and asks if he feels better. Without looking at her he says yes. Her dress, her figure, the expression of her face, the tone of her voice, all reveal the same thing. This is wrong. All he has lived for is falsehood and deception, hiding life and death from him. As soon as he admits that thought, the hatred and the pain spring up again, with a new grinding shooting pain and a feeling of suffocation. The expression on his face when he uttered that yes is dreadful. He looks her straight in the eyes, turns on his face with a rapidity extraordinary in his weak state, and shouts at her to go away, go away and leave him alone.