The sole answer to why a correct life ends in agony is the thought Ivan Ilyich will not keep: maybe he did not live as he ought. Late at night Praskovya Fedorovna comes in on tiptoe and wants to send Gerasim away so she can sit with him herself. Ivan has heard her. He shuts his eyes, then says no, go away, agrees to opium, and lets her leave. Till three in the morning he and his pain are shoved into a narrow black sack that has no bottom. He breaks through and wakes with his emaciated legs on Gerasim's shoulders, the same shaded candle, the same unceasing pain. Even this comfort he sends away. He waits until Gerasim has gone into the next room, then weeps like a child, for helplessness, loneliness, the cruelty of man, the cruelty of God, and the absence of God. Why hast Thou done all this? He does not expect an answer, and weeps because there can be none.
Then he grows quiet, holds his breath, and listens to an inner voice that asks what he wants. To live and not to suffer, he answers, to live as he used to, well and pleasantly. He calls up the best moments of that pleasant life. Only childhood still looks like something a person could live with, and the child who had it no longer exists. From the years that produced the present Ivan Ilyich, every joy melts into something trivial and often nasty. The School of Law still holds a little light-heartedness, friendship, and hope. The upper classes hold less. His first posting under the governor holds the memory of love for a woman. Then his marriage, a mere accident, his wife's bad breath, the sensuality and hypocrisy, and twenty years of deadly official life and money. He has been going downhill while he imagined he was going up: up in public opinion, down in life. Now it is all done, and there is only death.
A thought arrives that would solve the riddle: maybe he did not live as he ought. How could that be, when he did everything properly? He dismisses it as impossible. Then what does he want? To live as he lived in the law courts, when the usher proclaimed that the judge is coming? The judge is coming. Here he is. But I am not guilty. He turns his face to the wall and keeps asking why there is so much horror. Whenever the thought of a wrong life returns, he recalls the correctness of his whole life and dismisses so strange an idea.
Coming Up in Chapter 10
Another fortnight passes and Ivan no longer leaves the sofa. He lies with his face to the wall, asking what this is and hearing an inner voice answer yes, it is death. When he asks why he suffers, the voice has a short answer: for no reason. It just is so.