Chapter 18
Act IV, Scene 4 (cont.): The Verbal Duel
Now by my George, my Garter, and my Crowne Qu. Prophan'd, dishonor'd, and the third vsurpt Rich. I sweare Qu. By nothing, for this is no Oath: Thy George prophan'd, hath lost his Lordly Honor; Thy Garter blemish'd, pawn'd his Knightly Vertue; Thy Crowne vsurp'd, disgrac'd his Kingly Glory: If something thou would'st sweare to be beleeu'd, Sweare then by something, that thou hast not wrong'd Rich. Then by my Selfe Qu. Thy Selfe, is selfe-misvsed Rich. Now by the World Qu. 'Tis full of thy foule wrongs Rich. My Fathers death Qu. Thy life hath it dishonor'd Rich. Why…
Public-domain chapter text, formatted for reading.
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"Prophan'd, dishonor'd, and the third vsurpt"
Context: Elizabeth answering Richard's oath by George, Garter, and crown
Elizabeth refuses the symbols before the sentence finishes. Each honor Richard names is already void because he violated what it stands for.
In Today's Words:
Elizabeth says Richard's George is profaned, his Garter dishonored, and his crown usurped. That is how you answer someone swearing on badges they already broke. When a leader invokes rank or oath to sell trust, list what those symbols stood for before they reached for them.
"Thy broken Faith hath made the prey for Wormes."
Context: Elizabeth after Richard tries to swear by heaven
Elizabeth turns Richard's sacred appeal into forensic fact. The princes are worms' prey because his faith broke first.
In Today's Words:
Elizabeth tells Richard his broken faith put the princes where worms feed. She will not debate heaven with a man whose oaths already have corpses attached. When someone swears by the sacred after the harm is done, answer with the timeline and the bodies, not the symbol they invoke.
"But in your daughters wombe I bury them. Where in that Nest of Spicery they will breed Selues of themselues, to your recomforture"
Context: Richard answering Elizabeth that he killed her children
Richard's repair offer becomes horror. He asks a mother to treat her daughter's body as tomb and nursery for the boys he murdered.
In Today's Words:
Richard says he will bury her sons in her daughter's womb, where they will breed themselves to her comfort. That is annexation spoken as healing. When amends require the survivor's body to erase the dead, name it as seizure, not repair, and refuse the metaphor entirely.
"Shall I go win my daughter to thy will?"
Context: Elizabeth after Richard's threats and repair speech
The question sounds like surrender. It is exit strategy. Elizabeth buys departure with an answer Richard can hear.
In Today's Words:
Elizabeth asks whether she shall go win her daughter to Richard's will. The line lets a trapped person leave without confirming the deal is real. When you cannot safely refuse aloud, agreement to go elsewhere may be the first move, not the final promise you intend to keep.
Thematic Threads
Oaths Already Spent
In This Chapter
Elizabeth voids George, Garter, crown, heaven, and time because Richard's faith broke before he swore again
Development
Each new oath reveals how little sacred language he has left to spend
In Your Life:
When someone swears on symbols they already violated, answer with the violation, not the ceremony.
Exit Disguised as Consent
In This Chapter
Elizabeth asks shall I go win my daughter and promises to write shortly before exiting
Development
Richard hears relent; the scene ends before he learns it was strategy
In Your Life:
If yes is the only way out of the room, treat it as departure, not commitment, until the next move is yours.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
This is not a test. Five prompts guide you through the chapter, from how it opens to how it closes, so you notice context and rhythm rather than facts to memorize. Sit with each question in your own words. When you see "One way to read it," treat it as a starting point, not the only answer.
- 1
Why does Elizabeth answer each of Richard's oaths with the harm already attached to it?
analysis • surfaceOne way to read it
Richard swears by George, Garter, crown, self, heaven, and time; Elizabeth returns each as profaned, usurped, self-misused, or already wasted. Every oath object carries Richard's crime, so the swear-word cannot clean him.
- 2
What does the nest-of-spicery speech reveal about Richard's idea of repair?
analysis • mediumOne way to read it
Richard says he will bury the murdered princes in her daughter's womb where they will breed selves of themselves to her recomforture. He imagines murdered boys reborn as his heirs—a grotesque substitute for the children he killed.
- 3
How is Elizabeth's shall I go win my daughter different from genuine consent?
application • mediumOne way to read it
Elizabeth agrees to go and write shortly so she can exit an unsafe conversation. Feigned relent buys escape and time; Richard hears consent while she plans a different outcome with Richmond.
- 4
Why does Richard ask Elizabeth to plead what he will be, not what he has been?
application • deepOne way to read it
Richard needs a messenger for future fiction because past facts condemn him. He wants Elizabeth to sell prospective virtue, not account for princes already prey for worms.
- 5
When have you seen someone agree to leave and decide differently afterward?
reflection • deepOne way to read it
Agreement to exit is not agreement to comply. When someone says they will go think or consult, treat the yes as tactical retreat unless you control what happens after the door closes.
Critical Thinking Exercise
The Oath and Exit Analysis
Elizabeth dismantles Richard's oaths, then feigns relent to exit. Think of a time when agreement was a way to get out of an unsafe conversation.
Consider:
- •What is the difference between feigned relent and real consent?
- •Why does Richard need Elizabeth as messenger?
- •How does Elizabeth use timeline instead of symbol?
- •What would have been unsafe about an outright no?
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time you said yes to leave and acted differently later. What made exit possible?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 19: Act IV-V: Paranoia, Rebellion, & Buckingham's End
Richard calls her a shallow-changing woman; Richmond's navy appears, rebellions multiply, and Elizabeth has secretly pledged her daughter to Richmond instead.
