The damage is not wit but misread surfaces: readers praise dress and sound while thought stays thin or wrong underneath. Pope defines true wit as nature dressed to advantage, a thought many have had but never said so well, giving back the image already in the mind. Modest plainness sets off sprightly wit the way shade sets off light. Too much wit kills a work the way too much blood kills a body.
Other readers care only for language. Their praise is always "the style is excellent," and they take the sense on trust. Words pile like leaves while fruit of sense stays rare beneath. False eloquence spreads gaudy colour like a prism until nature's face disappears and everything glares alike. True expression is the steady sun: it gilds objects and alters none. A vile conceit in pompous words is a clown in purple. Styles must fit subjects as clothes fit country, town, and court. Fungoso struts in yesterday's fine clothes. Pope's rule for words as fashions: do not be first to try the new, nor last to drop the old.
Most judges score a poem by smooth or rough metre alone. Tuneful fools haunt Parnassus for the ear, as some attend church for music, not doctrine. Equal syllables, ten low words in one dull line, the cooling western breeze that must whisper through the trees, then sleep. A needless Alexandrine drags like a wounded snake. Ease in writing comes from art, like a learned dancer. The sound must echo the sense: Zephyr soft, surges hoarse, Ajax slow as he heaves a rock, Camilla fast as she skims the plain. Timotheus made Alexander burn and melt; that power, Pope says, is Dryden now.
Yet the crowd still mistakes performance for judgement. Some never advance an opinion and catch the town's spreading notion. Some praise the man, not the work, and worst is the critic at the great man's board who fetches nonsense for my lord. A hack's madrigal becomes thought the moment a lord owns the lines. Others damn whole ages or nations and force wit to shine on one sect. We think our fathers fools; our sons will think us so. What parties in wit do to parties of state is still ahead.
Coming Up in Chapter 7
Parties in wit next follow parties of state. Pride, malice, and folly rose against Dryden as parsons, critics, and beaux. Envy follows merit as a shadow. Pope will tell you to befriend true merit before the crowd commends, and warn that a jaundiced eye sees yellow in everything.