The first sip of learning makes a young critic drunk. Pope says drink deep from the Pierian spring, or do not taste it. A shallow draught heats the brain. A large draught sobers it. Youth, fired by the muse's first gift, climbs the Alps of art from a short view. They take the first clouds and snows for the last mountains, and they seem to walk on the sky. Then the way lengthens. Their eyes tire. Hills peep over hills. Alps rise on Alps.
The judge who has seen that second range reads a work in the spirit the author wrote it. He looks at the whole. He does not hunt slight faults for the dull joy of catching them, and so miss being charmed. Verse that stays cold and even, never rising or falling, cannot be blamed, yet it puts the reader to sleep. Nobody calls a face beautiful for one lip or one eye. A dome in Rome holds the eye because no single height or breadth startles; the whole is bold and regular together. Anyone who waits for a faultless piece waits for what never was. Ask what the writer meant to do. Nobody does more than they intended. If the means are just and the conduct true, clap even when small faults remain. Verbal critics hang the whole on one part, talk of principles, and sacrifice the work to one loved folly.
A bard meets La Mancha's knight on the road. The knight talks as sage as Dennis: anyone who leaves Aristotle is a sot. The bard shows a play that keeps subject, plot, manners, passions, and unities. Only the combat in the lists is missing, because knights, squires, and steeds will not fit the stage. The knight shouts to put them on anyway, or to build a new house, or to act the play in a field. That is a critic who loves a part more than the play. Some want a clever conceit in every line, a heap of wit with nothing that fits. Painters who cannot draw living grace paste gold and jewels on every inch. Poets do the same with ornament, and hide that they cannot make the thing itself.
Coming Up in Chapter 6
Pope next defines true wit as nature dressed to advantage: thought shared by many, said better than before. Others pile words like leaves and leave little sense underneath. He will ridicule rhymes that pair a cooling western breeze with trees that whisper, then insist that verse sound like the action, slow when Ajax lifts a rock, fast when Camilla crosses the plain.