When judgement tracks party lines, envy and fashion displace merit as the real test. Pope ties wit factions to political ones: public quarrels double private hate, and Dryden draws parsons, critics, and beaux in various shapes. The merry jests pass, but sense survives because rising merit still buoys up at last. If Dryden returned, new Blackmores and Millbourns would rise; if Homer lifted his head, Zoilus would start from the dead. Envy follows excellence the way a shadow follows a body, and even an eclipse can prove the sun's substance by showing the grossness of what blocks it. Strong beams at first draw vapours that hide the rays, yet those clouds may later adorn the day.
The praise that matters arrives early, not after the room has picked a side. Pope tells you to befriend true merit first, because praise is lost if you wait until all commend. Modern rhymes live a short date while fame that once lasted a thousand years now barely boasts threescore. Sons will watch their fathers' language fail, as Chaucer is to us, so Dryden shall be to them. A master's painted idea ripens until treacherous colours betray the art and the bright creation fades. Unhappy wit never atones for the envy it brings: it blooms like an early spring flower and dies in blooming, hard to guard and easy to lose.
On Parnassus, writers who reach the crown often employ their pains to spurn others down, and contending wits become the sport of fools while self-love rules each jealous author. Pope insists the critic must not lose the man in the role: good nature and good sense must join, and to err is human while to forgive is divine. If spleen remains, discharge it on crimes that deserve rage, not on every line that offends a sour temper.
Vile obscenity deserves no pardon, even when wit and art conspire to move the mind. In the fat age of ease, jilts ruled the state, statesmen wrote farces, pulpits spared satire, and licensed blasphemies groaned from the press. Pope tells critics to point thunder at those monsters, yet to shun readers so scandalously nice that they mistake an author into vice. When the eye is jaundiced, everything looks yellow, and the chapter leaves faction still threatening every honest verdict.
Coming Up in Chapter 8
Learn next what morals a critic must show. Silence when you doubt your sense. Speak even sure things with diffidence. Fools rush in where angels fear to tread. Pope will ask for the man who can show a friend's faults and praise a foe, then name Aristotle, Horace, Longinus, and Walsh.