A slighted appointment, a camp that cannot read the other camp, harshness used on equals, and a dirty offer you refuse, are four ways a house stakes itself without knowing. A republic should think twice before giving a great command to a citizen it has publicly wronged. Claudius Nero, slighted after Hasdrubal slips him in Spain, is later made consul against Hannibal. He leaves that army, marches to join the other consul, and stakes Rome's existence on beating Hasdrubal before the brothers meet. Asked why he played so dangerous a game without urgent need, he answers that success would restore the credit Spain had cost him, and failure would revenge him on the city that had spoken of him so cheaply. If a slight of that kind can move a Roman while the city is still uncorrupted, Machiavelli asks what it will do in a state not made as Rome then was. There is no sure remedy. A republic that lasts always is impossible, because ruin can arrive in a thousand unforeseen ways.
The highest quality in a captain is then to forestall the other side's design. You often read an enemy's actions worse than his intentions, especially the actions done under your eyes. Brutus wins his wing at Philippi; Cassius, beaten on his, thinks the whole army lost and kills himself. Swiss at Santa Cecilia stay on the field overnight, thinking they have won, and fight again at a disadvantage in the morning. The Pope and Spain cross the Po on the same false report and nearly walk into the French. Sempronius and the Equians both leave their camps, each sure the other has won, until the centurion Tempanius meets wounded Equians, takes both camps, and goes home a victor because he learned first. In 1498 at Marradi the Florentines and Venetians both decide to retreat at dawn from hunger. An old woman, too poor and old to be stopped, walks into the Florentine camp to visit kin and says the Venetians are already moving. Florence pursues as if it had driven them, and writes home a victory. Had the notice gone the other way, the same result would have gone the other way. Two opposed armies often fall into the same disorder. The one that soonest detects the other's distress comes off best.
Quintius then keeps an army of equals by kindness and comes home victorious. Appius, harsh, is so ill obeyed that he almost loses and must resign. Tacitus says a multitude is better punished than complied with. Machiavelli splits the cases. Over men who have been your equals, you cannot trust wholly to severity, unless you are a Manlius Torquatus of consummate valour. Over subjects used to being ruled, easiness breeds insolence, and punishment, kept moderate and kept off their property, is the safer tool. Quintius is more deserving of praise than Appius. Tacitus still merits approval once he is restricted to subjects, and not stretched over an Appius.
One humane act then opens Falerii. Camillus sends the schoolmaster back stripped, bound, and scourged by the boys he meant to sell, and the city yields. Those cities and provinces into which the engines of war have failed to force a way may be thrown open to a single act of tenderness, mercy, chastity, or generosity. Fabritius's warning drives Pyrrhus from Italy more than Roman arms. Scipio's restoring a wife in Spain wins more love than New Carthage. Xenophon loads Cyrus with the same kindness. Hannibal, by methods wholly opposite, still wins Italy.