A king who empties the old ordinances has already written the spark. Tarquin the Proud kills Servius, finds no heirs, and takes the kingdom. The monstrous means would still have been endured had he kept the ancient ordinances. He does not. He strips the senate, transacts in the palace what used to be done in public, and wears the commons with mechanic labour. Rome is already ready to rebel when Sextus violates Lucretia. Had Tarquin lived like the other kings, Brutus and Collatinus would have brought the offender to him, not to the people. Princes begin to weaken their authority from the hour they first violate the laws under which men have lived a great while. Timoleon and Aratus are loved because they govern well. Their peoples will not let them retire.
Conspiracies then take the rest of the chapter, because more princes die by them than by open war, and anyone can try. Tacitus: reverence the past, obey the present, wish for good princes, put up with any. Men conspire from universal hatred, from injuries to life, property, or honour, and from the wish to free a country. Threatening a life is more dangerous than taking it. The dead do not revenge. The threatened man must do or suffer, and becomes most dangerous. You can never strip a man so bare that he has no weapon, nor so far dishonour him as to quell revenge. Dishonours to the women of a household come first; then personal indignities, as with Pausanias and Philip, as with Giulio Belanti when Pandolfo takes back the daughter he had given him, as with the Pazzi when a law strips them of Giovanni Bonromei's inheritance. Against the humour that would free a country, no tyrant can guard except by laying down the tyranny. Plots with several hands are formed by intimates. Men of humble rank find no faith and no access. Excessive indulgence is as strong a motive as injury: Sejanus, Plautianus, Coppola, Jacopo against Gambacorti. A prince should leave his friends something still to desire. Danger sits in three stages: before, during, and after. Secrets leak by treachery, by a woman or boy, by conjecture from a sharpened dagger, as Scaevinus against Nero. Two arrested will not agree in a false account. The Pazzi keep fifty people quiet until the hour, which Machiavelli treats as a miracle. The only real safeguard is to impart the design at the moment it is to be done, as Nelematus locks the doors, as Darius says they go now or he accuses them, as Alasamenes is told and the rest only ordered to obey. Piso could have told his friends when Nero was already in the garden. Shun writing as you would a rock. Plautianus gives a written warrant and is undone. If you must tell one person, your denial can still match his assertion. Epicharis names no names and Nero lets her go. Necessity plots work the same way. Martia finds Commodus's list under a pillow and murders him that night. Macrinus reads a letter naming him and has Caracalla killed. Men are to be treated kindly or else got rid of, never brought to choose between slaying and being slain. Execution ruins a plot when the plan is changed without time to nerve new hands. The Pazzi move from a banquet to the cathedral because Giuliano will not come. Giovambattista of Montesecco will not kill in a church. Antonio of Volterra cries "Ah traitor" and Lorenzo lives. Quintianus cries that the senate sends this, and is seized before the blow. Reverence stops a slave over Marius in chains, and stops two brothers of Alfonso of Ferrara while a priest keeps bringing the duke to them. To strike two heads at once is almost hopeless: Diocles falls and Hippias avenges; the Pazzi kill only Giuliano. Pelopidas against ten tyrants is a marvel, not a pattern. A false alarm on the morning Caesar dies almost wrecks Brutus. A chance meeting in the street saves Pandolfo from Giulio Belanti. After the blow, the danger is the survivor. The Duke of Milan's son and brothers avenge him. Madonna Caterina of Forli enters the citadel on a promise, then from the walls scorns her own children as hostages and says she knows how others can be got. Worse still is a people that loved the dead man. Caesar's people drive the conspirators out, and they come to violent ends in different places. Plots against a country are slower to alarm a republic. Catiline speaks in the senate after discovery. Hanno's poison plot earns only a law on banquet expense. Pisistratus asks for a guard and becomes tyrant. Pandolfo takes a public guard others declined and rules Siena. Once executed, the new tyrant only inherits the ordinary dangers of a princedom. Poison is more uncertain: Commodus vomits it and must be strangled. If a plot is discovered and the plotters killed, men will still believe the prince invented it to glut himself. A prince who learns of a plot must weigh strength before he shows he knows. Rutilius keeps the Capuan legions quiet by seeming to continue their station, then separates them. The Duke of Athens seizes one man and loses Florence. Guglielmo de' Pazzi arrests one man in Arezzo without force and loses the town. Dion of Syracuse, to sound a man he suspects, lets Calippus pretend a plot, and so paves the road to his own death.
Changes from freedom to servitude, and back, are sometimes bloodless and sometimes reek with blood. Rome moves from kings to consuls with none banished save Tarquin. The Medici fall in 1494 with injury only to themselves. A government that came from the community can be withdrawn without a ledger of revenge. A government that began in violence injured many, and those injured will want blood when it falls.
He who would change a commonwealth must give heed to its character. Spurius Cassius offers the people Sicilian grain; they refuse the price of their freedom. Manlius Capitolinus, excellent gifts and all, is sentenced by the people themselves because the city is still uncorrupted. Not a kinsman puts on mourning. The tribunes side with the nobles against the common enemy. Livy: such was the fate of a man worthy of admiration had he not been born in a free state. Glory is sought by different methods in a free city and a corrupt one. Had he lived in the days of Marius and Sylla he might have succeeded. One man may prepare the ground for corruption; he cannot, in one life, wait for the harvest. It is no less arduous to free a people disposed to live in servitude than to enslave a people who desire to live free.