Mixed bodies last only if they are brought back to their first beginnings. States and sects have a first excellence by which they grow. Time rusts it. Physicians say something is daily added that will later need treatment. Rome is taken by the Gauls so she can be reborn: the old rites return, the Fabii who fought as envoys are punished, Camillus is trusted again. A reminder comes from outside, or from inside by a law that calls members to account, or by one rare life that works as a law. Tribunes and censors are the Roman machines. They still need a man who will enforce them against those who set them at defiance. The deaths of the sons of Brutus, of the Decemvirs, of Manlius Capitolinus, of Torquatus's son, of the Scipios, bring men back to the standard. Between one such vindication and the next, no more than ten years should pass. After that, manners change, fear fades, and so many offend together that you cannot punish without danger. Those who ruled Florence from 1434 to 1494 said five. Horatius, Scaevola, the Decii, and Regulus work almost as laws. After Regulus the examples thin. The two Catos stand too far apart; the younger finds a city he cannot move. Francis and Dominick, by poverty and the life of Christ, rekindle a dying faith, and also teach the people not to speak ill even of what is evil, which leaves prelates unafraid of punishments they neither see nor credit. France lasts by parliaments that will still sentence a prince. External force, as with the Gauls, can work. It is too hazardous to wish for.
Brutus then shows the first face of that return. He feigns folly so he can live, watch his patrimony, and wait. Livy names security. His acts name a second aim: he kisses the earth when the oracle speaks of the mother, and he is first to draw the dagger from Lucretia's wound. If you are strong enough, disclose hostility and make open war. If not, stand close to the prince, share his fortunes, and use the occasion. The middle course, neither near nor far, is praised and cannot be lived. A man of great station who asks only for a quiet life is not believed, and will not be left alone. To play the part he must say, do, see, and praise things contrary to his inclination.
To keep the freedom he has won, Brutus sits in judgment on his own sons and is present at their death. After a change of government, those hostile to the new order must be visited with signal punishment. He who sets up as a tyrant and slays not Brutus, and he who creates a free government and slays not the sons of Brutus, cannot last. Piero Soderini meets the same temper in Florence and will not strike. He believes patience and favours will mitigate enmity. He fears extraordinary powers would alarm the city and kill the gonfalonier-for-life after he is gone. The scruples are wise. An evil left to run its course may still prevail over the good. Ill-will is not vanquished by time nor propitiated by favours. From not knowing how to resemble Brutus, he loses power, fame, and his country.
An usurper is never safe while those he stripped still live. The elder Tarquin trusts a title given by people and senate, and the sons of Ancus are not content with what contents the rest of Rome. Servius loads the sons of Tarquin with favours; the new benefit is less than the injury, and they will not resign themselves to be the sons-in-law of a man they think should be their subject. His own daughter prizes a crown above a father. Old injuries are not healed by later gifts. The younger Tarquin will lose the kingdom by another road: not observing the ordinances of the old kings.