An exile's map, a siege that eats years, and a captain who must write home before he places a gun are three ways to spend a war you cannot keep. Alexander of Epirus comes into Italy invited by Lucanian exiles who promise him the whole land. Their fellow-citizens then offer restoration as the price of his death, and they pay it. Themistocles, proclaimed a traitor, flies to Darius and loads him with promises if he will only attack Greece. When he cannot keep them, he poisons himself. Faith lasts until another road home appears. Desire to return makes banished men believe what is untrue and designedly misrepresent the rest. Between what they think true and what they say they think, you are filled with impressions that ruin the man who builds on them. If Themistocles made that mistake, feebler natures will make a worse one.
Rome prefers another method for taking towns. Siege costs more than it returns, so they use it rarely. They take towns by assault or by surrender. Open force means a ring around the walls at the first onset, as Scipio takes New Carthage. If that fails it is rarely tried again: an army stretched around the walls is weak wherever a sally hits, and falls into disorder of itself. Battering, mines, timber towers, and mounds of earth then follow. Defenders throw up new works, meet mines with smoke-filled casks, burn the towers, and carry the earth off from inside as fast as it is heaped. If those fail, Scipio leaves Utica and turns on the Carthaginian army in the field, or a true siege begins, as at Veii, Capua, Carthage, Jerusalem. Secret understandings with men inside fail on a late hour, a goose in the Capitol, or a street no one knows. Aratus of Sicyon is a marvel by night and a coward by day: that is a quality in the man, not a method you can copy. Voluntary surrender comes from fear of a neighbour, as Capua, or from seeing good government elsewhere, as Rhodes and Massilia. Compulsory surrender comes from siege or from a wasted country. Rome, for four hundred and fifty years, wastes the country, beats armies in the field, and binds the rest by treaty. A siege can eat years. One field can give a kingdom in a day.
The senate then sends the consul out with nearly everything except peace and war. He may fight or decline, attack this city or that. Fabius routs the Etruscans near Sutrium and, without a word home, pushes through the Ciminian forest into a new and dangerous country. Two messengers sent to stop him arrive after a second victory, and go home to announce his glory. If the consul had to wait for advice from men not on the spot, he would be slower and less careful, because the credit would no longer be wholly his. Love of fame is both spur and curb. Venice and Florence reverse the rule. Their captains must write home before they place a single gun. That method, with the rest of their methods, has brought Italy to her present condition.
Coming Up in Chapter 27
Mixed bodies last only if brought back to their first beginnings. Rome is retaken after the Gauls, and the old rites return. Brutus feigns folly, then sits in judgment on his own sons. Piero Soderini will not strike, and is driven from Florence.