An unpaid insult, a darkened room, and gold paid for friendship are three ways a city falls while it still thinks it is strong. Gauls attack Clusium. Rome sends the three Fabii as envoys to tell them, in the name of the Roman people, to refrain. The envoys arrive as battle is about to join, and being readier at deeds than words, fight in the foremost Etruscan ranks. The Gauls turn their hatred on Rome. They demand the Fabii. The senate will not give them up or punish them. The comitia instead create them tribunes with consular powers. The Gauls take that as insult, march on Rome, and take it except the Capitol. The disaster comes from disregard of justice: men honoured who deserved to be chastised. The same pattern kills Philip of Macedon. Pausanias, foully dishonoured by Attalus, complains. Philip promises, then promotes Attalus to governor of Greece. On the morning of a daughter's wedding, walking between his son and his son-in-law, Philip is slain. A man deeply wronged, if not avenged to his satisfaction, will ruin a republic to pay the debt, or, under a prince, will not rest until he has paid it, though it cost him dear. Never think so lightly of any man as to suppose that wrong upon wrong will not teach him revenge.
Livy says Heaven meant the Romans to feel its power. The Fabii act amiss. Camillus, who alone could supply the remedy, is banished to Ardea, not put to death. No dictator is created, though the city had often named one against the Volscians. The army is weak and late, barely in time at the Allia, ten miles from Rome. The camp is pitched without trench or palisade. The battle is bloodless because the Romans flee before they are attacked. Most go to Veii. The rest make for the Capitol without turning aside to their homes. The senate does not even close the gates. Only the Capitol is defended with method: useless numbers kept out, victual brought in. Fortune, Machiavelli says, darkens men's minds when she would not have her ascendency gainsaid. Those at the extremes of good or evil fortune are little deserving of praise or blame. She chooses instruments. She removes those in her way by death or by stripping them of the means of good. She humbles Rome to raise her, takes the city but not the citadel, gathers an almost entire army at Veii and Camillus at Ardea, uncompromised by the reverse. Men may aid Fortune, not withstand her. They may interweave their threads with her web, not break it. They must never lose heart. Not knowing the end, and moving by crossroads, they always have room for hope.
One test of a state's strength is the terms on which it lives with its neighbours. If neighbours pay tribute for friendship, the state is strong. If it pays them, it is weak. Besieged in the Capitol, the Romans agree to buy the Gauls off with gold. At the moment of weighing, Camillus arrives. Fortune contrives that Rome shall not live thereafter as men ransomed for a price. Massilians, Eduans, Rhodians, Hiero, Eumenes, Massinissa pay Rome and ask only protection. Florence at the height of her renown pays every lordling of Romagna, the Perugians, the Castellans. Venice does the same. The French king lives tributary to the Swiss and to England, having disarmed his subjects to wring a present gain. They ransom themselves often. They buy towns they cannot defend with iron. Under the emperors Rome herself takes to purchasing peace, now from the Parthians, now from the Germans, and that is the beginning of decline. The method leaves the heart undefended and guards the hands and feet. When an enemy passes the frontier, Florence is over. Venice would have ended had the sea not girdled her. France totters when the English invade in 1513. Rome, after three defeats by Hannibal, still withstands him, because the people, the Latin league, the confederate towns, and the colonies are the heart. Hanno asks Hannibal's messengers whether anyone has come forward to propose peace, and whether any Latin or colony has revolted. They answer no. The war, he says, is no nearer an end than on the day it was begun. Where men are weak, Fortune shows herself strong, until someone following the ancients so controls her that she has not, with every revolution of the sun, a new occasion to display her power.