A rise from nothing, a humble answer to insolence, and a statement without a resolve are three ways a house loses: the first by a disguise, the second by teaching the other side you are weak, the third by missing the hour. Men seldom rise from small beginnings to great place without fraud or force, unless they inherit a seat someone else already holds. Force will never suffice by itself. Fraud often will. Philip of Macedon, Agathocles of Sicily, and others like them rise from low beginnings that way. Xenophon's Cyrus, on his first expedition against the King of Armenia, teems with fraud. He deceives his maternal grandsire Cyaxares in a variety of ways, and without that deceit he does not reach the greatness he comes to. Giovanni Galeazzo uses the same art to deprive his uncle Bernabo of Lombardy. Commonwealths must use those arts until they are powerful enough to trust to strength alone. Rome's greatest fraud is the method of making companions: under that name she made subjects. She uses Latin arms to subdue neighbours and gain reputation. The Latins never know they are enslaved until they see the Samnites twice routed. Distant princes then hear the Roman name. Those who both see and feel the arms grow jealous. The Latins, the colonies in Latium, and the Campanians whom Rome had just defended league against her, not by a direct attack but by defending the Sidicinians. Annius Setinus, addressing the Latin council, names it: slavery under the disguise of an equal alliance. The art is the less to be condemned, Machiavelli says, when it is skilfully concealed.
Humility is not merely of no service against insolent men. It is hurtful. The Romans, not wishing to offend the Latins, will not forbid them making war on the Samnites. The patience increases Latin confidence and hurries the hostility. Annius again: you have tried their patience by refusing them soldiers; they have put up with the affront; whence this forbearance if not from knowing our strength and their weakness? A prince should never stoop from his dignity. If he would have credit for a concession, he must be able to withhold it. When you cannot give way with credit, it is better that a thing be taken by force than yielded through fear of force. Yield to escape war and you often do not escape it. The other side wrings further concessions and accounts you weak. Friends grow less zealous. Prepare to resist, even if weaker, and neighbouring princes think more of you, and many will assist who would not have stirred a finger had you despaired. If you have several adversaries, restore something to one of them even after war is declared, so as to detach him.
Weak states are always dubious in their resolves, and tardy resolves are always hurtful. The Romans, suspecting the Latins, ask for eight citizens to consult. The Latins call a council to decide whom to send and what to say. Annius tells them it is of far greater moment to consider what they are to do than what they are to say. When the resolve is formed, fit words are easy. Where there is doubt, you cannot suit words to conduct. Machiavelli has watched that uncertainty hinder Florence to its detriment. In hard cases the delay comes from want of spirit, want of strength, or from men who, wanting to overthrow the government or to serve themselves, will suffer no decision. Good citizens, even when the popular mind is bent on a dangerous course, will not oppose a fixed plan in a matter that will not wait. After Hieronymus is killed, Syracuse cannot choose Rome or Carthage until Apollonides says the sides are not to blame, only the doubt and delay. The Lavinians, urged by the Latins to help against Rome, take so long that their army is issuing from the gates when word comes that the Latins are already beaten. Millionius, their praetor, says that with the Romans this short march will cost them dear. Had they granted aid at once, they might have won. Had they refused at once, they would not have offended Rome. By delay they stand to lose in every way. Florence, tardy toward Lodovico when Louis XII comes into Italy, tries to ratify when the king is already on the eve of victory. The king will not accept a consent given under constraint. It costs the city dear and goes near to lose her freedom. Lodovico, had he won, would have shown her still less goodwill than the king did.
Coming Up in Chapter 21
The most momentous battle Rome fought with another nation is the Latin day under Torquatus and Decius. The armies match in language, arms, and obstinacy. Something extra has to happen: Torquatus slays his son, Decius dies by his own hand, and the captains of Machiavelli's day have already discarded the method.