A look can already name a man as dead, and the evening can still be spent mending a small organ until the pain returns in the dark. Just before the New Year, Ivan Ilyich's brother-in-law arrives, a healthy, florid man unpacking his own portmanteau. Ivan Ilyich comes home from the law courts and meets that stare. The brother-in-law opens his mouth to exclaim and checks himself. "I have changed, eh?" "Yes, there is a change." After that he will say nothing more about looks. Ivan Ilyich locks the study, examines himself full face and in profile, compares the glass with a portrait taken with his wife, and sits on an ottoman, blacker than night. "No, no, this won't do." Law papers will not hold him. On tiptoe at the drawing-room door he hears Praskovya Fedorovna say her brother is exaggerating. The reply is that he is a dead man: look at his eyes; there is no life in them. No one knows, she answers. Nikolaevich said something; Leshchetitsky said the contrary.
He walks away and tries the smaller story. A floating kidney can be caught, arrested, and supported. So little is needed. He rings for the carriage. Praskovya asks, with a specially sad and exceptionally kind look, where he is going, and the kindness irritates him. With Peter Ivanovich he sees a doctor friend. There is something small in the vermiform appendix. Stimulate one organ, check another, and absorption will put it right. He comes home late, eats, converses cheerfully, and cannot for a long time go back to his room, because an important, intimate matter has been put aside. After work he remembers that the matter is the appendix, and still does not give himself up to it. He takes tea with callers. They play the piano and sing. Praskovya remarks that he spent the evening more cheerfully than usual. At eleven he goes to the small room where he now sleeps alone, takes up a Zola novel, and does not read it. In his imagination the appendix improves. One need only assist nature. He takes his medicine, touches his side, finds it is not painful, and puts out the light. He is already feeling better, much better.
The old dull gnawing pain returns, and the loathsome taste. Appendix, kidney: it is not a question of either, but of life and death. Life was there and now it is going, and he cannot stop it. Why deceive himself? Isn't it obvious to everyone but him that he is dying, a matter of weeks, days, this moment? He jumps up, drops candle and candlestick, and stares into the dark. Through the door, a song and its accompaniment. They are merry, the beasts. He tries to think it from the beginning: the knock on the side, the doctors, the abyss, no light in his eyes. He leans down for matches, grows furious with the stand, upsets it, and falls back expecting death at once. Visitors are leaving. Praskovya hears the fall, brings a candle, and finds him panting like a man who has run a thousand yards. "No...no...thing. I upset it." She will not understand. She hurries away to see another visitor off, comes back, and offers Leshchetitsky, regardless of expense. He smiles malignantly and says no. She kisses his forehead. He hates her from the bottom of his soul and almost pushes her away. "Please God you'll sleep." He tells her yes.
Coming Up in Chapter 6
Ivan Ilyich now sees that he is dying, but he cannot take it in. A schoolbook syllogism about a man named Caius, who is mortal, seems true of everyone except little Vanya, who loved a striped leather ball. He tries to hide in his work at the law courts, but something he calls It keeps looking at him.