A respectable career can be terrible without a crime if every step is the one people of rank would have taken. Tolstoy puts the verdict first: Ivan Ilyich's life had been most simple and most ordinary and therefore most terrible. He dies at forty-five as a member of the Court of Justice, second son of Ilya Epimovich Golovin, a Privy Councillor whose posts are fictitious and whose salaries of six to ten thousand roubles are not. Ivan is le phénix de la famille, neither as cold as the elder brother nor as wild as the younger, who is avoided and forgotten. At the School of Law he is already what he will remain. He considers his duty to be what those in authority consider it. Acts that once disgusted him fade once people of good position do them too. He leaves with clothes from Scharmer, a medallion inscribed respice finem on his watch-chain, a dinner at Donon's, and a provincial post under the governor bought with his father's influence.
In the province he treats the sectarians with honest pride, and also keeps a milliner, an outlying street of doubtful reputation, and a tone of good breeding that lets no hard name stick. It is all done with clean hands, clean linen, and French phrases, among people of rank. The reformed courts of 1864 make him an examining magistrate. He likes writing a few words that can bring anyone before him, and he likes still more the chance to soften that power. He learns to drop his own opinion and reduce every case to its paper externals. After two years he dances with Praskovya Fedorovna Mikhel, the most attractive girl of his set, and asks himself why he should not marry. She has a little property and the right connections. Attraction and his circle's approval both sway him. He does not have to choose which.
The marriage is pleasant until she is pregnant. Jealousy and coarse scenes arrive without, as he tells himself, any reason. He invites friends for cards, then uses official work as a fence: dinner, housewife, and bed are all he requires of home. He rises to Assistant Public Prosecutor, then Public Prosecutor. Two children die after the move, then another. A daughter is educated at home and turns out well. A son becomes a subject of dissension and is entered at the High School to spite his father. Veiled hostility becomes the goal of family life, not a failure of it. On the whole his life continues to flow as he thinks it should: pleasantly and properly.
Coming Up in Chapter 3
After seventeen years of marriage, Ivan Ilyich expects to be made presiding judge in a university town. Instead a man called Happe gets the post, and Ivan quarrels with his superiors and finds that his salary no longer stretches. A sleepless night on the veranda sends him to Petersburg, looking for any position that pays five thousand roubles.