Richard III Ch. 4: Act I, Scene 4: Clarence's Murder

William Shakespeare

Act I, Scene 4: Clarence's Murder

0:00

0:00 / 0:00

0:00

Summary

Clarence tells the Tower keeper he has passed a miserable night. In his dream he escapes with Gloucester, walks the hatches, and is struck overboard into a sea of wrecks, gnawed corpses, and jewels lodged in dead men's skulls. The nightmare continues after death: Warwick and Prince Edward's bloody ghost condemn him for perjury and Tewkesbury before fiends howl him awake.

Brakenbury delivers the sleeping duke to two murderers bearing a warrant. The killers argue conscience against pay, decide Clarence must die awake, and find him asking for wine. Clarence appeals to law, Scripture, and brotherhood, insisting Edward would not murder him for old Lancastrian sins they share.

When Clarence sends them to Gloucester for a richer reward, they tell him the truth: his brother hates him and ordered the killing. Clarence cites Richard's tears and embrace; they stab him and drown him in a malmsey butt. One murderer repents and wishes Richard knew he tried to save Clarence; the other hides the body and waits for payment.

In this chapter: Terms Characters Key Quotes Modern Story

Why This Matters

Recognizing the Proxy Kill

Some harm arrives through intermediaries so the person who ordered it can keep performing loyalty. Clarence appeals to law and brotherhood, then learns Gloucester sent the killers; he still trusts the tears over the warrant.

Believe the commission and the payment trail before the hug you remember.

Coming Up in Chapter 5

The dying King Edward forces a deathbed reconciliation among the warring lords, not knowing Clarence is already dead until Richard drops the news in front of the court The dying King Edward gathers the court and forces a public peace. He makes Rivers and Hastings swear love, pulls the Queen into the embrace, and takes Buckingham's oath before turning to the reconciliation he wants.

Lessons

What this chapter proves — the patterns beneath the scene

All lessons

In this chapter: Charm Without a Person · Grief Aimed at a Vote.

The cards below name the patterns this chapter proves — carry them with you into the original text.

Charm Without a Person

Clarence cannot accept that Gloucester wants him dead. He remembers the sobs, the arms around him, the deep disgrace in brotherhood. The murderers have the warrant. Clarence still treats the performance as love because it looked expensive enough to be real.

Key Insight

People who survive Richard watch what he does after the hug. Clarence dies because he treated the hug as the evidence.

“Simple plain Clarence, I do love thee so, that I will shortly send thy soul to Heaven.”

Full analysis

Grief Aimed at a Vote

Clarence cannot believe his brother wants him dead. He remembers Richard weeping over his arrest, hugging him, swearing with sobs. The murderers have the warrant. Clarence still treats the performance as evidence of love, because the feeling looked expensive enough to be real.

Key Insight

A public tear is not a feeling. It is a prop. Clarence dies because he trusted the cost of the performance instead of the pattern of the man.

PreviousPrevious Chapter NextNext Chapter

Original text

2,268 wordscomplete

Chapter 04

Act I, Scene 4: Clarence's Murder

Scena Quarta. Enter Clarence and Keeper. Keep. Why lookes your Grace so heauily to day Cla. O, I haue past a miserable night, So full of fearefull Dreames, of vgly sights, That as I am a Christian faithfull man, I would not spend another such a night Though 'twere to buy a world of happy daies: So full of dismall terror was the time Keep. What was your dream my Lord, I pray you tel me Cla. Me thoughts that I had broken from the Tower, And was embark'd to crosse to Burgundy, And in my company my Brother Glouster,…

Public-domain chapter text, formatted for reading.

Critical Thinking Exercise

8 minutes

The Proxy Pattern

Richard eliminates Clarence through others. Think of someone who consistently benefits from others' removals without directly causing them.

Consider:

•How do you distinguish between coincidence and pattern?
•What are the signs of indirect manipulation?

Master this chapter. Complete your experience

Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature

Buy at

Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats

King Lear

William Shakespeare

Also by William Shakespeare

Hamlet

William Shakespeare

Also by William Shakespeare

Dead Souls

Nikolai Gogol

Explores power & authority

Noli Me Tángere

José Rizal

Explores power & authority

More lessons from Richard III

Other theme-by-theme analyses from this book.

Deep diving the literary elements.

Act I, Scene 4: Clarence's Murder

Summary