Moby-Dick Ch. 83: Jonah Historically Regarded

Herman Melville

Jonah Historically Regarded

0:00

0:00 / 0:00

0:00

Summary

Ishmael says some Nantucketers do not believe the Bible story of Jonah and the whale. Greeks and Romans once doubted stories about Hercules and Arion too. But doubting a story does not make it untrue.

An old whaleman called Sag-Harbor had several reasons for doubt. His old Bible had a picture of Jonah's whale with two spouts on its head. That is what right whales have, not sperm whales. Right whales also have very small throats. Fishermen say a penny roll would choke one.

Bishop Jebb answered that Jonah might not have been in the whale's belly at all. Maybe he sat in the whale's mouth. A right whale's mouth is huge enough for card tables, though the whale has no teeth.

Sag-Harbor also worried about stomach acid and digestion. Scholars answered with stranger ideas: Jonah hid inside a dead floating whale like soldiers sleeping in dead horses. Or he swam to another ship with a whale carved on the bow. Or the whale was just an inflated bag Jonah used as a life preserver.

Then there was the map problem. Jonah was swallowed in the Mediterranean Sea but vomited up near Nineveh, which is far inland. That trip seems impossible in three days. One priest even said the whale went around Africa by the Cape of Good Hope, which would be an even bigger miracle.

Ishmael lists all these answers to show Sag-Harbor is beaten on every point. Then Ishmael turns against the skeptic. He says Sag-Harbor shows foolish pride of reason and rebellion against clergy. Turks still believe Jonah's story. There is even a mosque with a lamp that burns without oil.

Ishmael sides with faith communities over the sailor's doubts.

In this chapter: Terms Characters Key Quotes Modern Story

Why This Matters

Hearing Doubt Without Collapse

Founding stories face plate errors, anatomy jokes, and map math. Ishmael stacks Sag-Harbor's objections then stacks clerical answers, finally calling pride of reason impious while Turks keep faith.

Before you shut down a coworker who doubts the company myth, list which objections are factual and which are morale battles dressed as logic.

Coming Up in Chapter 84

Next Ishmael describes pitchpoling. Queequeg greases the bottom of his whaleboat so it slides faster on the water. Stubb learns to throw a long lance at a running whale from a rocking boat.

PreviousPrevious Chapter NextNext Chapter

Original text

769 wordscomplete

Chapter 83

Jonah Historically Regarded

Jonah Historically Regarded. Reference was made to the historical story of Jonah and the whale in the preceding chapter. Now some Nantucketers rather distrust this historical story of Jonah and the whale. But then there were some sceptical Greeks and Romans, who, standing out from the orthodox pagans of their times, equally doubted the story of Hercules and the whale, and Arion and the dolphin; and yet their doubting those traditions did not make those traditions one whit the less facts, for all that. One old Sag-Harbor whaleman’s chief reason for questioning the Hebrew story was this:—He had one of…

Public-domain chapter text, formatted for reading.

Critical Thinking Exercise

10 minutes

Objection and Reframe

Pick a story your org tells. What is the strongest skeptic point and the cleverest reframe?

Consider:

•Evidence?
•Morale?
•Labels?

Journaling Prompt

Write about when doubt was called disloyalty.

Master this chapter. Complete your experience

Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature

Buy at

Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats

Crime and Punishment

Fyodor Dostoevsky

Explores identity & self

The Idiot

Fyodor Dostoevsky

Explores identity & self

Frankenstein

Mary Shelley

Explores identity & self

As I Lay Dying

William Faulkner

Explores identity & self

Identity & Self-Discovery

Lessons from Moby-Dick

Theme-by-theme analyses that connect this book to modern life skills.

Deep diving the literary elements.

Jonah Historically Regarded

Summary