Reading Competing Perspectives
Fifty-Nine Versions of the Same Corpse
Darl tries to teach Vardaman that was does not mean is. Jewel's horse is not his mother. The coffin is was, not is. Vardaman answers with a question Darl cannot close. Language splits along grief lines. The brother who sees most clearly is also the one everyone will later call mad.
Key Insight
Grammar fights are family fights. When someone insists on was versus is, they are usually arguing about permission to stop carrying the dead as if they were still present.
“Was is not is.”Explore full theme analysis






