Within and Without
Tom takes him off the train, upstairs, into Myrtle's apartment. Nick drinks. He watches Tom break her nose for saying Daisy's name. He does not leave. He later finds the sentence that will excuse the afternoon: he was within and without, enchanted and repelled. The double position feels like intelligence. It is also how you stay at a party after the blood.
Key Insight
Both-and is a narrator's gift and a citizen's failure. If you can be inside the room and above it at once, you will never have to choose a door. Nick's most famous self-description is a method for remaining.
“I was within and without, simultaneously enchanted and repelled by the inexhaustible variety of life.”Full analysis






