The city is well defended even by dishonour if the army lives, a forced promise does not bind the people once the pressure is gone, a nation keeps the vices you have already paid for, and presence that leaves no time to refuse can win what envoys could not. The consuls and the whole Roman army fall into the hands of the Samnites and are told to strip their arms and pass under the yoke before they may go home. The army is overwhelmed. Lucius Lentulus, the lieutenant, stands forward and says they ought to decline no course whereby the country might be saved. The existence of Rome depends on the preservation of her army. That army must be saved at any sacrifice. Honourable or ignominious, all is well done that is done for the defence of the country. If the army is preserved, Rome may in time wipe out the disgrace. If it is destroyed, however gloriously it perishes, Rome and her freedom perish with it. His counsel is followed. Machiavelli then tells every citizen called to advise: when the entire safety of the country is at stake, no consideration of what is just or unjust, merciful or cruel, praiseworthy or shameful, must intervene. The French, he says, listen with impatience to the remark that a course is disgraceful to the king. Their king can incur no disgrace by any resolve, whether it turn out well or ill.
When the disarmed legions return, Spurius Posthumius, himself one of the consuls, contends in the senate that the terms made in the Caudine Valley do not bind the Roman people, though they bind him and those who promised. If the people wish to be free of the engagement, he and the rest must be made over as prisoners to the Samnites. The senate adopts it. Fortune is kind: the Samnites will not keep him, and Rome holds the defeated consul in higher honour than victorious Pontius is held by his countrymen. Two points follow. Glory may be won by any action, even by a defeat seen to happen through no fault of yours, or cancelled by a valiant action directly after. There is no disgrace in not observing promises wrung from you by force. When they affect the public welfare they will always be broken once the pressure is withdrawn, and without shame. Between princes, even unforced promises are disregarded when the causes that led to them no longer operate. Whether princes ought to follow those methods has already been considered in his book on princes.
Men born in the same province then keep nearly the same character through all times. He who would forecast what is about to happen should look to what has been, because the same passions produce the same effects, though training raises those passions in one province and not another. Florence has already paid Charles VIII to restore the fortresses of Pisa and not received them, and paid an emperor a hundred thousand ducats on setting out and another hundred thousand at Verona only to watch him turn back, alleging that certain persons had failed to fulfil their engagements. The Etruscans, overpowered by Rome, paid Gauls to unite against the Romans, and the Gauls, after taking the money, refused to arm, saying they had been paid only to refrain from pillaging Etruscan lands. The people of Etruria were at once defrauded of their money and disappointed of the help they had counted on. The same avarice, pride, cruelty, and perfidy, in ancient times and in recent, with all men alike. If Florence had not been urged by passion or overcome by necessity, or had she read the ancient usages of those nations, she would neither on this, nor on many other occasions, have been deceived. Another aid toward judging the future is to watch how the same nation long retains the same customs, remaining constantly covetous or deceitful. A prince who trusts a nation without reading how it has always used other men will pay twice for the same vice.
The Samnites, unable to stand against Rome without help, then leave garrisons in their towns and pass with the main army into Etruria, which is at truce with Rome, to see whether their presence in arms might move the Etruscans to renew hostilities they had refused when invited through envoys. They say they have risen because peace is a heavier burden for slaves than war for freemen. The presence of the army decides them. When you would obtain something, leave the other no time to deliberate. Julius II marches on Bologna before France and Venice can make up their minds to thwart him, having had only hesitating answers when he sounded them. The king sends soldiers. The Venetians stay aloof. M. de Foix waits until his men are already on the march before asking the Marquis of Mantua for leave to pass the short road through lakes and forts. Taken aback, the marquis yields, though he is in league with the Venetians and the Pope and has a son in the Pope's hands, which would have given him fair pretexts for refusal. Neither power could make up its mind to thwart him in the brief time allowed, and both knew that refusal would be violently resented. Ordinary methods had failed. Hardihood still had a clock.