Victory is a prior conviction among people who already know one another, honours should rest on a first notable deed not a name, the first person to own a new measure owns the wreck, and a first rush without drill is gone before the fight is over. An army is certain it will prevail when it is well armed and disciplined, and when the soldiers know one another, which is found only in men born and bred in the same country. They must also think well of the captain: careful of their welfare, attentive to discipline, brave, keeping his word, making the path to victory look easy, and concealing or making light of distant dangers. Rome adds religion. Consuls are appointed, armies enrolled, and battles begun only when the auguries favour. Claudius Pulcher is punished for joining battle against them. Appius Claudius, complaining that the tribunes strip religion of authority, says the fowls and the coop are small matters, and that by not contemning such small matters the forefathers built the republic. In those small matters lies a power that keeps men united and of good courage. Religion without valour still avails nothing. The men of Praeneste camp on the Allia, where the Gauls once routed Rome, to hearten themselves and dismay the enemy. The dictator tells his master of the knights to fall on their centre anyway: they have chosen the ground in reliance upon fortune; you rely on discipline and valour. Two Manlii, surprised while part of the army is foraging, are saved by the soldiers' steadfast valour, not by the consuls' foresight. Livy: even without a leader the steadfast valour of the soldiers was maintained. Fabius, leading for the first time into Etruria against a new foe, recites many reasons for expecting a victory, then says he could have mentioned others that make victory certain, had it not been dangerous to disclose them.
A people then confers honours by descent, by the company a man keeps, or by one remarkable action that is not yet of public moment. The third is the safest. Pedigree misleads so often that men are slow to trust it. Manners are safer than blood and still inferior to deeds, because until there is proof, credit is only opinion and can change. A first notable action, a law for the general well-being, or an accusation of a powerful citizen, gives a name that later contrary acts can destroy only by many repetitions. Titus Manlius begins by rescuing his father from a tribune, later takes the twisted collar from a Gaul and the name Torquatus, and later still puts his own son to death for fighting without leave, though successfully. Those three actions outlast his triumphs, because in the victories many resembled him and in these he stood almost alone. The elder Scipio is made less by the sum of his victories than by rescuing his father at the Ticino, by forcing the youth after Cannae to swear they will not abandon the country, and by restoring a wife in Spain. A prince who would be esteemed must give the same signal proofs, by words or deeds that promote the public good, until magnanimity, generosity, and justice pass into a proverb among his subjects. When first honours rest on descent, company, or one notable action, the foundation is reasonable. When many instances of noble conduct have already made a man known, there is hardly room for mistake. A people can still be deceived as to character, an error a prince is less likely to fall into because advisers warn him. Wise founders therefore make it lawful, when the highest dignities would be dangerous in incapable hands, for any citizen to declare the favoured candidate's defects in public. When the people are about to choose an incapable man for a dangerous post, Rome makes it honourable to declare his defects in the assembly. Fabius Maximus speaks against Titus Ottacilius in the second Punic war and turns the favour toward someone who deserves it more. So far as first honours go, a people advised in that way commits fewer mistakes than a prince. The citizen who would begin still has to perform, like Manlius, some noteworthy action.
It is then perilous to be the first to recommend a new measure, and the more unusual the measure the greater the danger. Men judge by results. Evil is imputed to the author. Good is applauded, and still what a man may gain is as nothing to what he may lose. Selim, urged by a bashaw to turn from Egypt against the Sofi, wins a battle in a waterless plain and loses so many to pestilence and famine that he puts the adviser to death. The first plebeian consul is routed, and only a powerful party saves the men who had forwarded the law. The counsellor's dilemma is duty against place and life. Machiavelli's remedy is to offer the opinion without heat, so the city or prince adopts it of their own goodwill and does not seem dragged by your importunity. You lose the glory of standing alone. You escape the combination of those who opposed you. If other counsels prevail and mischief comes, your credit is enhanced, which is no cause for rejoicing and is still something. Silence will not save you. Perseus, defeated, hears a companion point out the mistakes that ruined him and kills him for waiting until there was no remedy.
The Gauls, at the beginning of a fray, are more than men, and ere it is ended less than women. Nature is part of that. Training can still keep them brave to the end. Armies are of three kinds. The Roman kind has discipline, and bravery as its consequence: none eat, sleep, buy, or sell without the consul's order, and trained valour uses fury when occasion requires and does not lose heart. The Gallic kind has impetuosity without discipline: unless the first attack succeeds, the fury cools and they have nothing else. The Italian armies of Machiavelli's day have neither natural spirit nor trained valour, and win only when the enemy takes to flight by accident. Papirius Cursor, denouncing what would follow if Fabius his master of the knights were absolved for disobedience, lists a vagrant soldiery, disregarded auspices, deserted standards, and an army grown from a solemn and consecrated company to a dark and fortuitous gathering of cutthroats. It is easy, Machiavelli says, to pronounce which description fits the armies of his times.