Plutarch and other grave writers say Rome owed her empire more to Fortune than to valour. They point to the temples she built for that deity, more than for any other. Livy almost never puts a speech of valour in a Roman mouth without naming Fortune too. Machiavelli will not have it. No commonwealth grew like Rome because none was so well fitted by its institutions. Her armies spread the empire. The founder's methods kept what they took. The same writers call it luck that she never fought two great wars at once. He answers that the sequence is a method. One war seemed to go out as another broke: Equians and Volscians, then Samnites, then Latins with Samnium in league, then Etruscans, then Pyrrhus, then Carthage, then the Gauls, then Hannibal, then Macedon and Antiochus. Before the last victory, anyone watching the order of the wars would have seen valour and prudence as well as good fortune. A potentate so feared that no neighbour will engage him single-handed can almost choose his wars and keep the rest quiet. Distant powers treat the matter as too remote until the fire is at their own doors. Carthage holds Africa, Sicily, and Sardinia, courts Rome's friendship, and discovers the mistake only when Rome assails Spain and Sicily. In a new province they always sought a friend as a ladder: Capuans, Camertines, Mamertines, Saguntans, Massinissa. Nations that take that precaution stand in less need of Fortune's help.
Nothing then gave Rome so much trouble as the love of freedom in the countries round about. From the mountains that divide Tuscany from Lombardy down the peninsula lived free nations: Etruscans, Romans, Samnites. Etruria, when Veii created a king for its defence, would lend no help while they lived under a king. It was useless, they judged, to defend a country given over to servitude by its own inhabitants. States never signally increase except under a free government. Athens after Pisistratus is the proof. Rome after her kings is the stranger one. A republic will do what helps the community even when it hurts this man or that. A tyrant cannot honour the valiant lest he have cause to fear them, and cannot make acquired cities subject to his own city, because a powerful city is not for his interest. Hieronymus is slain in Syracuse; the army, hearing the cry of liberty in the streets, lays aside its resentment and falls to consider a free government. Corcyra, recovering with Athenian help, smothers the nobles in the ruins of their prison. A lost freedom is avenged with more ferocity than a threatened freedom is defended. Present training is milder, Machiavelli says, because the religion of his day teaches little account of worldly glory, while the Gentiles placed their highest good there and were fiercer in action. The mass hope to be received into Paradise and think more how to bear injuries than how to avenge them. He will not blame the religion: it permits the exaltation and defence of one's country. False interpretations have given the world over as a prey to wicked men. The Roman Empire also put an end to the free states of antiquity, and they could never recover. The Samnites, while free, fought Rome for six and forty years down to Papirius Cursor, and later tell Hannibal they had fought her for a hundred years with their own soldiers and captains, more than once against two consuls. Once subjugated, ill-treated by a legion at Nola, they can scarce defend themselves against that one poor legion. Free countries fill with children and with wealth. The hardest servitude is one commonwealth subjected to another.
Rome grows on Alba's ruins. Fill a city by gentleness, an open path to strangers, or by force, destroying neighbouring towns and transplanting the people. Rome practised both. Under the sixth king, eighty thousand citizens fit to bear arms lived within the walls. The husbandman cuts the first shoots so the stem may later put forth stronger branches. Sparta and Athens, well armed and well lawed, never reached the same greatness. Rome could put two hundred and eighty thousand under arms. They never more than twenty thousand. Lycurgus feared that strangers would relax his laws, refused them marriage and citizenship, and made the money of leather. A puny stem cannot carry a great branch. After Thebes rebelled, Sparta's other cities rebelled, and the trunk was stripped of its boughs. Rome's stem could bear any branch. How a commonwealth should extend that power, by league, by companions, or by direct subjection, has not yet been named.