Chapter 17
The Vicar's Honest Compromises
“The clerkly person smiled and said Promise was a pretty maid, But being poor she died unwed.” The Rev. Camden Farebrother, whom Lydgate went to see the next evening, lived in an old parsonage, built of stone, venerable enough to match the church which it looked out upon. All the furniture too in the house was old, but with another grade of age—that of Mr. Farebrother’s father and grandfather. There were painted white chairs, with gilding and wreaths on them, and some lingering red silk damask with slits in it. There were engraved portraits of Lord Chancellors and other celebrated…
Public-domain chapter text, formatted for reading.
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"One must be poor to know the luxury of giving!"
Context: Describing Miss Noble's habit of saving sugar for poor children
Miss Noble's tiny thefts are more Christian than Bulstrode's ledgers. Eliot praises giving that costs the giver something real, not display that purchases power.
In Today's Words:
Watching Miss Noble hide sugar for poor children, Eliot says one must be poor to know the luxury of giving. The line turns thrift into moral imagination and praises cost that the giver actually feels. Generosity that hurts your store is different from charity that buys influence and calls itself virtue.
"If you vote for me you will offend Bulstrode."
Context: Explaining Middlemarch party politics to Lydgate
Farebrother states the bargain without melodrama. Support has a price, and neutrality is not available once institutions need your name on a side.
In Today's Words:
Farebrother told Lydgate plainly that voting for him would offend Bulstrode, with no heroics attached to the warning. In tight communities, choosing the better person can still function as choosing the worse enemy you must live beside. Neutrality disappears the moment an institution asks for your name on a side.
"I look for the man who will bring the arsenic, and don’t mind about his incantations."
Context: Separating Bulstrode's religion from his usefulness to hospital reform
The metaphor is blunt and self-serving. Lydgate wants the practical benefit while treating belief as noise, a habit that will make later compromise feel rational.
In Today's Words:
Lydgate said he wanted the man who would bring the arsenic and did not care about the incantations. He meant he would take Bulstrode's hospital help and ignore the theology. Separating useful patrons from their motives sounds smart until the bargain starts choosing your votes for you.
"And I am not a model clergyman, only a decent makeshift."
Context: Explaining why Bulstrode wants him replaced at the hospital
Self-deprecation here is also strategy. Farebrother admits limits, wins trust, and quietly exposes how church politics mixes salary, doctrine, and personality.
In Today's Words:
Farebrother shrugged that he was not a model clergyman, only a decent makeshift. The joke lowered defenses while telling the truth about salary, doctrine, and personality mixing in church politics. People who admit their limits can earn more trust than those who wrap every preference in providence.
Thematic Threads
Authenticity
In This Chapter
Farebrother admits his flaws openly rather than maintaining clerical pretense
Development
Contrasts with earlier characters who hide behind social roles
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when deciding how much of your real self to show at work or in new relationships.
Class
In This Chapter
The household dynamics reveal different class attitudes, Mrs. Farebrother's old-fashioned certainty vs Miss Noble's quiet charity
Development
Continues exploring how class shapes daily behavior and expectations
In Your Life:
You see this in how different generations in your family handle money, work, or social obligations.
Political Navigation
In This Chapter
Farebrother warns Lydgate about the social consequences of aligning with Bulstrode
Development
Introduces the political undercurrents that will drive later conflicts
In Your Life:
You face this when choosing sides in workplace politics or community disputes.
Compromise
In This Chapter
Farebrother accepts he's 'not a model clergyman, only a decent makeshift'
Development
Shows mature acceptance of imperfection while maintaining effectiveness
In Your Life:
You experience this when realizing you can't be the perfect parent, employee, or partner but can still do good work.
Hidden Kindness
In This Chapter
Miss Noble secretly saves food scraps for poor children
Development
Introduced here as quiet generosity without recognition
In Your Life:
You might notice this in people who help others without seeking credit or acknowledgment.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
This is not a test. Five prompts guide you through the chapter, from how it opens to how it closes, so you notice context and rhythm rather than facts to memorize. Sit with each question in your own words. When you see "One way to read it," treat it as a starting point, not the only answer.
- 1
What does the contrast between Farebrother's drawing room (with three ladies managing him) and his private study (with insects and tobacco) reveal about his position in Middlemarch society?
analysis • surfaceOne way to read it
The drawing room shows his public role as dutiful son and clergyman, while his study reveals his true interests and compromises. He's trapped between family expectations and personal fulfillment.
- 2
Why does Farebrother describe himself as 'only a decent makeshift' rather than defending his calling as a clergyman? What does this self-assessment accomplish in his conversation with Lydgate?
analysis • mediumOne way to read it
His honesty disarms potential criticism and creates trust with Lydgate. By admitting his limitations first, he gains credibility when warning about Bulstrode's political maneuvering.
- 3
How might a modern professional who feels trapped in the wrong career relate to Farebrother's situation with his entomology hobby and clerical duties?
application • mediumOne way to read it
Like someone working in corporate law while dreaming of environmental science, Farebrother pursues his passion as a side interest while fulfilling family obligations and financial needs.
- 4
If you were Lydgate, how would you weigh Farebrother's warning about Bulstrode against your own medical ambitions for hospital reform?
application • deepOne way to read it
The dilemma involves choosing between personal integrity and professional advancement. Farebrother offers friendship but limited resources, while Bulstrode offers funding but potential moral compromise.
- 5
What does Miss Noble's habit of secretly saving sugar for poor children suggest about how people navigate between social expectations and personal conscience?
reflection • deepOne way to read it
Her 'pleasant vice' shows how genuine compassion often operates through small, hidden acts rather than grand gestures. True charity may require discretion to avoid social judgment.
Critical Thinking Exercise
Practice Strategic Honesty
Think of a relationship where you feel like you have to maintain a perfect image. Write down three minor flaws or struggles you could appropriately share that might actually strengthen the connection. For each one, explain how you manage that flaw rather than just complaining about it.
Consider:
- •Choose flaws that show you're human without undermining your competence
- •Focus on how you handle challenges, not just the challenges themselves
- •Consider what the other person might relate to or appreciate hearing
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when someone's honest admission of their struggles made you trust them more. What made their honesty feel genuine rather than like they were seeking pity?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 18: The Weight of Small Compromises
The chaplaincy vote moves from dinner talk to real consequence. Lydgate discovers that reform in Middlemarch means choosing sides under the polite fiction that professional judgment floats free of patronage and spite.
