Ancient rules were discovered, not devised: nature methodised, liberty restrained by laws nature first ordained. Greece showed her sons the steep paths up Parnassus, held the prize aloft, and drew precepts from examples that had themselves come from heaven. The generous critic fanned the poet's fire. Criticism was the muse's handmaid, until later wits, unable to win the mistress, wooed the maid, turned the poets' own arms against them, and hated most the men they learned from. Modern apothecaries play doctor from the bills, prescribe by mistaken rules, and call their masters fools. Some prey on ancient leaves worse than moths. Some write dull receipts for poems, displaying learning and explaining the meaning away.
Anyone who would steer judgement must know each ancient's character, fable, subject, scope, religion, country, and age. Without those before the eyes, you may cavil but never criticise. Make Homer your study by day and night, compare the text with itself, and let Virgil comment. Young Maro meant a work to outlast Rome and seemed to scorn the critic's law; when he examined every part, nature and Homer were the same, and he confined the labour as if Aristotle watched each line. To copy nature is to copy those rules. Yet some beauties have no precept. Where rules do not reach, a lucky licence that still serves the intended end becomes a rule. Pegasus may leave the common track. Great wits may gloriously offend, snatch a grace that hits the heart without passing through judgement, as a shapeless rock or hanging precipice can please the eye.
Kings may dispense with laws they made; moderns must offend seldom, by need, and with precedent, or the critic seizes fame and puts his laws in force. Figures look monstrous up close; due distance restores grace. A prudent chief sometimes conceals force and seems to fly. Those are often stratagems, not errors: it is not Homer who nods, but we who dream. Ancient altars stay green with bays. Pope asks for a spark to teach vain wits a science little known: to admire superior sense, and doubt their own.
Coming Up in Chapter 4
Pride next is the never-failing vice of fools: nature recruits it where worth is denied, and it swells like wind in a thin body. Where wit fails, pride fills the void of sense. Pope will tell you not to trust yourself, but to know your defects, and to use every friend and every foe.