Navigating Moral Complexity
Pirate custom matters until it threatens Silver's life. The gentlemen's code matters until lives are at stake. Both groups invoke principle when it helps and abandon it when it does not. Jim learns to read principles as tools people use under pressure, not as fixed identities that guarantee behavior.
Key Insight
Expect inconsistency under pressure. Loyal, professional, and righteous are descriptions people reach for. They are not a forecast of the next hour.






