Chapter 39
Why Poets Lie Too Much
“Since I have known the body better”—said Zarathustra to one of his disciples—“the spirit hath only been to me symbolically spirit; and all the ‘imperishable’—that is also but a simile.” “So have I heard thee say once before,” answered the disciple, “and then thou addedst: ‘But the poets lie too much.’ Why didst thou say that the poets lie too much?” “Why?” said Zarathustra. “Thou askest why? I do not belong to those who may be asked after their Why. Is my experience but of yesterday? It is long ago that I experienced the reasons for mine opinions. Should I…
Public-domain chapter text, formatted for reading.
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"“Since I have known the body better”—said Zarathustra to one of his disciples—“the spirit hath only been to me symbolically spirit; and all the ‘imperishable’—that is also but a simile."
Context: Opening statement to his disciple about how his understanding has changed
This reveals Zarathustra's shift from abstract spiritual thinking to a more grounded, physical understanding of human experience. He's saying that once you really understand how the body works, spiritual concepts become just metaphors rather than literal truths.
In Today's Words:
Once I really understood how the body works, all that talk about spirit and soul started sounding like poetry rather than fact. Words like eternal or imperishable are just useful comparisons, not literal truths. Understanding the physical machinery of being human changes how you hear every claim about what supposedly lasts forever.
"— Belief doth not sanctify me, said he, least of all the belief in myself."
Context: Response to his disciple's declaration of faith in him
Zarathustra rejects the idea that belief makes something sacred or true. Even self-confidence doesn't automatically make you right. This shows his commitment to questioning everything, including his own authority.
In Today's Words:
Being believed in does not make me right, and believing in myself doesn't make my words true. The disciple's faith in me is touching, but it's no substitute for truth. If I were to rely on my own certainty as proof of anything, I would be exactly the kind of liar I'm warning you about.
"We also know too little, and are bad learners: so we are obliged to lie."
Context: Explaining why poets lie too much
This is a confession about the fundamental problem with trying to be wise or artistic - you're expected to have answers when you really don't know enough. So you end up making things up to fill the gaps in your knowledge.
In Today's Words:
Poets are expected to speak profoundly about everything, but the truth is we barely understand the things we're asked to illuminate. That gap between expectation and actual knowledge is where the lies live. We don't make things up out of malice but out of the pressure to sound wiser than we are.
"Verily, their spirit itself is the peacock of peacocks, and a sea of vanity!"
Context: Zarathustra's final verdict on poets after cataloguing all their shallow performances and self-serving lies
This compressed image captures the fundamental problem: poets who should be in service of truth and beauty have instead made themselves the center of the spectacle. Like a peacock showing its feathers, they are more invested in being seen as beautiful than in actually seeing anything. Their spirit seeks an audience, not truth.
In Today's Words:
The spirit of every poet, including mine, turns back on itself and struts around demanding to be admired. Instead of using creativity to understand life more deeply, they've made creativity into a performance about themselves. All that apparent depth is really just vanity looking at its own reflection and calling it insight.
Thematic Threads
Intellectual Honesty
In This Chapter
Zarathustra admits he's a liar and questions his own methods of teaching through poetry and metaphor
Development
Introduced here as self-critique
In Your Life:
You might catch yourself giving confident opinions about things you don't really understand
Performance vs. Authenticity
In This Chapter
Poets are described as peacocks—all beautiful display but shallow substance, seeking spectators rather than truth
Development
Introduced here
In Your Life:
You might notice when you're speaking to impress rather than to genuinely communicate or help
Self-Awareness
In This Chapter
Zarathustra turns his critical eye on himself, recognizing his own participation in the very patterns he criticizes
Development
Evolved from earlier chapters where he criticized others
In Your Life:
You might realize you're guilty of the same behaviors you criticize in others
Class and Pretension
In This Chapter
The critique of poets as 'half-and-half' people who muddle waters to seem deep reflects broader class anxieties about intellectual pretension
Development
Continues theme of questioning social hierarchies based on supposed wisdom
In Your Life:
You might recognize when people use complex language or mysterious behavior to seem more important than they are
Growth Through Disillusionment
In This Chapter
Zarathustra predicts poets will grow tired of their vanity and become 'penitents of the spirit'
Development
Introduced here as pathway beyond current limitations
In Your Life:
You might find that growing up means letting go of impressive-seeming beliefs that don't actually serve you
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
This is not a test. Five prompts guide you through the chapter, from how it opens to how it closes, so you notice context and rhythm rather than facts to memorize. Sit with each question in your own words. When you see "One way to read it," treat it as a starting point, not the only answer.
- 1
Why does Zarathustra admit that poets, including himself, are liars?
analysis • surfaceOne way to read it
He argues that poets know too little but are expected to speak with deep authority, so they fill the gap between actual knowledge and audience expectations with beautiful-sounding lies rather than honest uncertainty.
- 2
What drives poets to perform wisdom instead of seeking truth, according to Zarathustra?
analysis • mediumOne way to read it
He argues the applause for beauty becomes addictive and the expectation of profundity creates pressure. Poets start privileging the appearance of wisdom over the difficult, unrewarded work of actually pursuing it through honest inquiry.
- 3
Zarathustra compares poets to peacocks, all beautiful display but shallow substance. Where do you see this peacock pattern in the creative or intellectual worlds you encounter today?
application • mediumOne way to read it
Social media rewards beautiful presentation over substance. The accounts with the most followers often have the most aesthetic consistency rather than the deepest thinking, creating incentives that reward performance over genuine inquiry.
- 4
Zarathustra says he finds 'a fugitive creature in my dovecote, which is alien to me.' What does it feel like to discover a thought in your own mind that seems foreign to you, and what do you do with it?
application • deepOne way to read it
These alien thoughts often point toward growth or unresolved conflict. The honest response is to examine them rather than dismiss them, since thoughts that feel foreign often carry information we need and can't yet comfortably own.
- 5
Zarathustra predicts that poets will eventually become 'penitents of the spirit,' growing tired of their own vanity. Have you gone through a phase of performing expertise or wisdom that you later found hollow? What prompted the change?
reflection • deepOne way to read it
This kind of disillusionment usually arrives when the gap between performance and genuine understanding becomes too uncomfortable to sustain. Some external challenge or honest conversation breaks through the performance and makes the pretense impossible to maintain.
Critical Thinking Exercise
Audit Your Own Expertise
Make two lists: areas where you have real, earned expertise (through work, experience, or deep study) and areas where people ask your opinion but you're mostly guessing or performing knowledge. Be brutally honest. Then identify one area where you've been tempted to sound wise beyond what you actually know.
Consider:
- •Real expertise comes from sustained experience, not just reading about something
- •It's okay to have opinions outside your expertise, just label them as such
- •The pressure to seem knowledgeable is strongest in areas where you have some credibility
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you felt pressure to have an answer or opinion about something you didn't really understand. How did you handle it, and what would you do differently now?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 40: The Fire-Dog: Confronting False Prophets
Zarathustra's journey takes him to a mysterious smoking island near his Happy Isles, where local legends speak of a volcano that serves as a gateway to the underworld. What truths await in this ominous place?
