Chapter 07
Why We Can't Connect with Love
Of those passions which take their origin from a particular turn or habit of the imagination. Even of the passions derived from the imagination, those which take their origin from a peculiar turn or habit it has acquired, though they may be acknowledged to be perfectly natural, are, however, but little sympathized with. The imaginations of mankind, not having acquired that particular turn, cannot enter into them; and such passions, though they may be allowed to be almost unavoidable in some part of life, are always in some measure ridiculous. This is the case with that strong attachment which naturally…
Public-domain chapter text, formatted for reading.
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"The passion appears to every body, but the man who feels it, entirely disproportioned 42to the value of the object; and love, though it is pardoned in a certain age because we know it is natural, is always laughed at, because we cannot enter into it."
Context: Love as the paradigm of unsympathetic passion
Lovers feel proportion; spectators do not. The asymmetry explains social ridicule of romantic intensity.
In Today's Words:
From inside love, every gesture feels sized to the beloved; from outside, the same passion looks absurdly large. Smith is describing a structural mismatch, not saying love is false. The lover is not lying about inner proportion; observers simply cannot import that scale into their own breasts.
"Our imagination not having run in the same channel with that of the lover, we cannot enter into the eagerness of his emotions."
Context: Failed imaginative channel-sharing
Sympathy requires parallel imaginative history. Without similar experience, spectators treat passion as foreign comedy.
In Today's Words:
We mock or shrug at lovers because our imagination has not traveled their road. Without running the same mental channel, we cannot generate their feeling in ourselves. That is why passionate people feel unseen: others are not refusing care so much as failing to simulate.
"If our friend has been injured, we readily sympathize with his resentment, and grow angry with the very person with whom he is angry."
Context: Contrast with love: injury invites sympathy more easily
Wrong done to a friend gives spectators a clear scene to enter. Romantic joy lacks that narrative hook for outsiders.
In Today's Words:
Tell us your friend was wronged and we can join your anger quickly because injustice gives us a story we know how to enter. Tell us you are blissfully in love and we often withdraw because joy without obstacle is harder to share. Smith maps which passions travel socially and which stay private.
"There is in love a strong mixture of humanity, generality, kindness, friendship, esteem; passions with which, of all 45others, for reasons which shall be explained immediately, we have the greatest propensity to sympathize, even notwithstanding we are sensible that they are, in some measure, excessive."
Context: Love contains shareable elements spectators ignore
Smith complicates the mockery: love is compound. Observers fixate on the ridiculous excess and miss the humane sub-passions.
In Today's Words:
Love is not only dizzy infatuation; it blends kindness, friendship, and esteem, which are usually easy to sympathize with. Spectators still fixate on the silly parts because those are what break proportion. Smith hints that better sympathy might attend to the humane mixture, not only the performance.
Thematic Threads
Social Connection
In This Chapter
Smith shows how our most meaningful experiences can paradoxically disconnect us from others
Development
Builds on earlier chapters about sympathy by revealing its limits
In Your Life:
You might notice how talking about your biggest interests sometimes makes people uncomfortable or distant
Emotional Boundaries
In This Chapter
The necessity of reserve about our deepest feelings to maintain social relationships
Development
Introduced here as a practical social strategy
In Your Life:
You probably already edit what you share based on who you're talking to, even if you don't realize it
Human Relationships
In This Chapter
Why we connect more with others' struggles than their pure happiness
Development
Extends the sympathy concept to explain why tragedy resonates more than joy
In Your Life:
You might find yourself more engaged when friends share problems rather than successes
Identity
In This Chapter
The challenge of being fully known when our passions seem excessive to others
Development
Shows how social expectations shape which parts of ourselves we reveal
In Your Life:
You likely have different versions of yourself for different social contexts
Personal Growth
In This Chapter
Learning to navigate the gap between internal experience and external expression
Development
Practical wisdom about managing our social presentation
In Your Life:
You might need to develop better strategies for sharing what matters most to you
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
This is not a test. Five prompts guide you through the chapter, from how it opens to how it closes, so you notice context and rhythm rather than facts to memorize. Sit with each question in your own words. When you see "One way to read it," treat it as a starting point, not the only answer.
- 1
Why does Smith single out romantic love as especially hard for third parties to sympathize with?
analysis • surfaceOne way to read it
Love feels proportionate only to the person inside it. Spectators lack the imaginative channel the lover has built. Without that history, the passion looks excessive and even comic.
- 2
How does injury to a friend produce sympathy more readily than a friend's romantic happiness?
analysis • mediumOne way to read it
Injury supplies a clear scene of wrong that outsiders know how to enter. Romantic joy lacks conflict and may even trigger envy. Smith shows that morality of attention is uneven across passions.
- 3
What passion of yours has made others glaze over even though it matters enormously to you?
application • mediumOne way to read it
Personal answer. The pattern includes career obsessions, creative projects, spiritual commitments, and fandom. Smith explains isolation as failed simulation, not necessarily selfishness in the passionate person.
- 4
How can you share something you love without demanding that others feel it at the same intensity?
application • deepOne way to read it
Lead with obstacles, stakes, or human elements outsiders can enter. Ask for specific kinds of support rather than full emotional merger. Smith's lesson is audience matching, not silence about what matters.
- 5
When does social mockery of love protect people from folly, and when does it merely punish sincerity?
reflection • deepOne way to read it
Mockery can check delusion, but it often punishes vulnerability. Smith describes the mechanism of ridicule without fully endorsing it. Readers should ask whether laughter is correcting proportion or refusing to grant dignity.
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Passion Circles
Draw three circles representing your main life areas (work, family, hobbies, etc.). For each circle, write what you're most passionate about in that area. Then honestly assess: which of these passions would bore or alienate people in your other circles? Create a strategy for sharing each passion only with people who can connect with it.
Consider:
- •Notice which passions you've been oversharing with the wrong audiences
- •Identify people in your life who might be doing this same thing to you
- •Consider how this affects your relationships when passion-sharing goes wrong
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when your excitement about something important to you was met with indifference or eye-rolls. How did that feel, and how might you handle it differently now?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 8: When Anger Serves Justice
Smith now turns to examine the darker side of human emotion; those antisocial passions that don't just fail to connect us with others, but actively drive us apart. What happens when our feelings become truly destructive?
