Chapter 10
The Social Cost of Success
Of the selfish passions. Besides those two opposite sets of passions, the social and unsocial, there is another which holds a sort of middle place between them; is never either so graceful as is sometimes the one set, nor is ever so odious as is sometimes the other. Grief and joy, when conceived upon account of our own private good or bad fortune, constitute this third set of passions. Even when excessive, they are never so disagreeable as excessive resentment, because no opposite sympathy can ever interest us against them: and when most suitable to their objects they are never…
Public-domain chapter text, formatted for reading.
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"The man, who, by some sudden revolution of fortune, is lifted up all at once into a condition of life, greatly above what he had formerly lived in, may be assured that the congratulations of his best friends are not all of them perfectly sincere."
Context: Sudden elevation and social ridicule
Rapid success breaks imaginative continuity. Spectators cannot keep time with the upstart's new joys.
In Today's Words:
When someone jumps suddenly into a much grander life, others struggle to sympathize with their happiness and often respond with ridicule instead. The problem is not merit; it is pace. Smith says our imaginations need gradual change to enter another person's good fortune without envy or disbelief.
"An upstart, though of the greatest merit, is generally disagreeable, and a sentiment of envy commonly prevents us from heartily sympathizing with his joy."
Context: Envy attends sudden prosperity
Merit does not erase social friction. Envy is Smith's frank name for spectator resistance to another's rise.
In Today's Words:
Even deserving people who rise fast can feel disagreeable because their success triggers envy before admiration. Smith is blunt: we often resent prosperity we did not travel toward gradually. That resentment is a moral problem for spectators as much as a PR problem for the successful.
"we are generally most disposed to sympathize with small joys and great sorrows."
Context: Asymmetry in sympathy for fortune
Modest pleasures invite sharing; towering success does not. Tragedy pulls harder than triumph.
In Today's Words:
We join small pleasures and large griefs more easily than huge successes. A coworker's good lunch is easier to celebrate than their promotion to executive. Smith names an uncomfortable bias: sorrow travels farther socially than joy, especially when joy is large. Smith's point is that moral spectatorship begins in imagination: we picture another's situation before we approve or condemn the feeling that situation provokes.
"He redoubles his attention to his old friends, and endeavours more than ever to be humble, assiduous, and complaisant."
Context: How the newly elevated try to recover sympathy
Sudden winners compensate with humility and attention. They sense the sympathy deficit and work to close it.
In Today's Words:
People who rise quickly often hustle to stay likable: more humility, more checking in, more careful manners. Smith sees this as rational repair of a sympathy break, not mere performance. The successful person knows old friends are slipping away and tries to buy back emotional continuity.
Thematic Threads
Class
In This Chapter
Success creates instant class barriers—old friends see betrayal, new circles see intrusion
Development
Builds on earlier class themes by showing how mobility itself becomes the problem
In Your Life:
Notice how your own success or others' changes your social dynamics, even with family
Identity
In This Chapter
Sudden fortune creates identity crisis—you're no longer who you were but not yet accepted as who you're becoming
Development
Deepens identity exploration by showing external success can destabilize internal sense of self
In Your Life:
Major life changes often leave you feeling like you don't belong anywhere
Human Relationships
In This Chapter
Relationships strain under success because we sympathize more with small joys than great triumphs
Development
Continues relationship analysis by revealing how good news can damage bonds
In Your Life:
Your biggest victories might be the hardest to share with the people closest to you
Social Expectations
In This Chapter
Society expects gradual rise—sudden elevation violates unspoken rules about 'staying in your place'
Development
Expands on social pressure themes by showing expectations apply even to positive changes
In Your Life:
People may punish you for changing too quickly, even in positive directions
Personal Growth
In This Chapter
True growth requires managing not just your own response to success but others' reactions to your changes
Development
Advances growth themes by adding social navigation as essential skill
In Your Life:
Your personal development affects everyone around you, requiring careful relationship management
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
This is not a test. Five prompts guide you through the chapter, from how it opens to how it closes, so you notice context and rhythm rather than facts to memorize. Sit with each question in your own words. When you see "One way to read it," treat it as a starting point, not the only answer.
- 1
Why does sudden elevation appear 'ridiculous' even when the person deserves success?
analysis • surfaceOne way to read it
Spectators cannot imaginatively follow a leap they did not witness step by step. Joy at a new level feels disproportionate because their sympathy was calibrated to the old life.
- 2
How does envy differ from justice-based criticism in Smith's account of the upstart?
analysis • mediumOne way to read it
Envy attends prosperity itself, not necessarily wrongdoing. Merit may be real and envy still present. Smith forces readers to inspect their own resistance to others' gains.
- 3
When have you struggled to celebrate someone else's success honestly?
application • mediumOne way to read it
Personal answer. Smith's asymmetry rule explains why promotions, windfalls, and glow-ups can chill friendships. Naming envy is the first step toward repairing sympathy.
- 4
If you experience sudden success, what practical steps does Smith suggest for keeping old bonds?
application • deepOne way to read it
Redouble attention to old friends, practice humility, avoid displaying new joys at full volume, and show continued interest in their lives. The goal is to rebuild imaginative continuity, not to hide achievement.
- 5
Does Smith think societies should slow mobility to preserve sympathy, or train spectators better?
reflection • deepOne way to read it
He describes psychological limits more than policy. Readers may conclude that moral work lies with spectators who confuse envy with judgment and with the successful who must navigate sympathy deficits wisely.
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Success Reactions
Think of three people in your life who have experienced different levels of success recently - someone with a small win, someone with a moderate achievement, and someone with a major breakthrough. Write down your honest first reaction to each person's news. Then analyze: which was easiest to celebrate genuinely? Which triggered any negative feelings? What does this reveal about your own psychology?
Consider:
- •Be honest about any jealousy or resentment - these are normal human reactions
- •Notice if your reaction changed based on how close you are to the person
- •Consider whether the person's attitude about their success affected your response
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when your own success created unexpected distance in a relationship. What would you do differently now, knowing what Smith teaches about human psychology?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 11: Why We Feel Others' Pain More Than Their Joy
Smith will examine why our sympathy for others' pain, while stronger than our sympathy for their joy, still falls far short of what the suffering person actually feels. This gap between observer and experience shapes how we judge others' reactions to both triumph and tragedy.
