Chapter 19
The Third Attack
Now that this treasure, which had so long been the object of the abbé’s meditations, could insure the future happiness of him whom Faria really loved as a son, it had doubled its value in his eyes, and every day he expatiated on the amount, explaining to Dantès all the good which, with thirteen or fourteen millions of francs, a man could do in these days to his friends; and then Dantès’ countenance became gloomy, for the oath of vengeance he had taken recurred to his memory, and he reflected how much ill, in these times, a man with thirteen…
Public-domain chapter text, formatted for reading.
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"and then Dantès’ countenance became gloomy, for the oath of vengeance he had taken recurred to his memory"
Context: Faria speaks of millions while Edmond hears a war chest
Wealth and revenge occupy the same number in Edmond's mind. Faria imagines charity; Edmond imagines ammunition.
In Today's Words:
When someone finally names a sum large enough to change a life, listeners often hear different futures in the same figure. Faria hears help for friends. Edmond hears the cost of settling scores with men who prospered while he rotted. Money becomes moral quickly when it arrives after injustice.
"gallery on the sea side, which had long been in ruins, was rebuilt. They had repaired it completely"
Context: Prison authorities seal the route Faria and Edmond had used
The state repairs what prisoners opened. Progress underground is erased without ceremony.
In Today's Words:
Just when two people think their hidden work has bought a path out, the institution patches the wall without even knowing who dug it. That is how systems respond to pressure points: not with mercy, but with maintenance. Hope built on a secret tunnel can vanish in a single afternoon of official repairs.
"Monte Cristo, forget not Monte Cristo!” And he fell back on the bed."
Context: Faria's dying words during the final attack
The last command is not revenge but coordinates. Treasure becomes a legacy handed to the living.
In Today's Words:
A dying mentor does not finish with rage. He finishes with a place name, as if geography could outlive stone and officials. That is what legacy sounds like when time runs out: not a speech, but a location the survivor must remember long after the body goes cold.
"he saw that he was alone with a corpse."
Context: Closing after dawn confirms Faria is dead
Edmond crosses from companionship to horror. The teacher is now inventory the prison will remove.
In Today's Words:
Edmond has prayed for this man's death as an escape route and now cannot touch the open eyes. Grief and strategy collide in one room. Many people discover that the moment opportunity finally opens is also the moment loss becomes undeniable. The pattern is not abstract. It shows up whenever someone with leverage decides the outcome before the conversation even begins.
Thematic Threads
Fortune
In This Chapter
Faria expatiates on thirteen or fourteen millions while Edmond hears vengeance.
Development
Wealth shifts from rumor to daily speech just as the men who could use it are running out of time.
In Your Life:
Large opportunities often arrive when emotional bandwidth is already spent.
Institutional cruelty
In This Chapter
Officials heat irons on Faria's heel and joke about the cheap burial sack.
Development
The prison treats the dead as refuse, teaching Edmond how little humanity remains in procedure.
In Your Life:
Bureaucracies often show their values most clearly in how they handle bodies.
Solitude
In This Chapter
Edmond ends alone with the corpse, afraid to touch the open eyes.
Development
Companionship becomes horror at the exact moment the next escape step becomes thinkable.
In Your Life:
The loneliest beats often follow the loudest breakthroughs.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
This is not a test. Five prompts guide you through the chapter, from how it opens to how it closes, so you notice context and rhythm rather than facts to memorize. Sit with each question in your own words. When you see "One way to read it," treat it as a starting point, not the only answer.
- 1
Faria suffers a third cataleptic attack and tells Edmond how to use the red liquid if he appears dead. Why must Edmond hide any cry from the jailer?
analysis • surfaceOne way to read it
If officials think Faria is dying, they may move him and separate the two men forever. Silence protects their tunnel and their bond.
- 2
Faria warns that this attack may paralyze him for life or kill him, yet Edmond swears by Christ never to leave him. How does that oath change the escape plan?
analysis • mediumOne way to read it
Flight becomes secondary to loyalty. Edmond accepts that freedom may wait until he can carry or save his teacher, not abandon him for the ladder and sea.
- 3
Faria's burning-heel test for true death horrifies Edmond. Where do people learn harsh methods to tell hope from final loss?
application • mediumOne way to read it
Think of medical training, disaster work, or caregiving where experience teaches ugly checks before grief is allowed. Desperation breeds precise rituals.
- 4
When Faria speaks of what millions could do for friends, Edmond's face darkens with his vengeance oath. How does wealth collide with revenge in his mind?
application • deepOne way to read it
Faria imagines charity and renewal. Edmond hears the war chest for punishing Danglars, Fernand, and Villefort. The same fortune carries two futures.
- 5
The chapter ends with Edmond alone with Faria's corpse, sealing the tunnel before the jailer comes. What does that solitude foreshadow?
reflection • deepOne way to read it
Freedom may require inhabiting death. Edmond's next step will mean taking the dead man's place, not walking out as himself.
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Phoenix Moments
Think of a time when you or someone you know went through a major setback that forced them to become a completely different person. Draw a simple before/after comparison showing the old identity, the crisis that destroyed it, and the new identity that emerged. Focus on specific skills, attitudes, or strengths that only existed after the transformation.
Consider:
- •What assumptions about life or people had to die for the new person to emerge?
- •What new capabilities or knowledge became possible only after the old identity was destroyed?
- •How did the person's relationship with trust, power, and self-protection change?
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you had to completely reinvent yourself after a major loss or betrayal. What version of yourself had to 'die' and what emerged in its place? What would you tell someone currently going through their own Phoenix Process?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 20: The Cemetery of the Château d'If
Faria lies in his canvas winding-sheet on the bed while Edmond must decide whether he can take the dead man's place and be carried out of the Château d'If as a corpse.
