Chapter 16
Missing What We Can't Have
XVI “Do you miss your friend greatly?” asked Mademoiselle Reisz one morning as she came creeping up behind Edna, who had just left her cottage on her way to the beach. She spent much of her time in the water since she had acquired finally the art of swimming. As their stay at Grand Isle drew near its close, she felt that she could not give too much time to a diversion which afforded her the only real pleasurable moments that she knew. When Mademoiselle Reisz came and touched her upon the shoulder and spoke to her, the woman seemed…
Public-domain chapter text, formatted for reading.
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"going had some way taken the brightness, the color, the meaning out of everything. The conditions of her life were in no way changed, but her whole existence was dulled, like a faded garment which seems to be no longer worth wearing."
Context: Opening assessment of Edna's mood
Absence reorganizes her emotional world. Ordinary days feel drained of purpose.
In Today's Words:
Without him color drained from everything. When someone becomes your reference point, their absence can make competent life feel grayscale. At work, in caregiving, or in close relationships, the same pressure appears when duty outruns choice and someone finally names what they will no longer pretend is inevitable.
"I would give up the unessential; I would give my money, I would give my life for my children; but I wouldn’t give myself."
Context: Argument with Madame Ratignolle about sacrifice
She distinguishes survival from soul. Motherhood does not own her inner life.
In Today's Words:
She said she would die for her children but not surrender her self. Loving family and refusing self-erasure can coexist though others may call that selfish. At work, in caregiving, or in close relationships, the same pressure appears when duty outruns choice and someone finally names what they will no longer pretend is inevitable.
"Her favorite son! Oh, dear! Who could have been imposing such a tale upon you? Aline Lebrun lives for Victor"
Context: Mocking Edna's sympathy for Madame Lebrun losing Robert
Reisz punctures sentimental stories. She offers bitter clarity instead of comfort.
In Today's Words:
Reisz laughed at the idea that Robert was the favorite son. People who see through family myths can sound cruel while naming power accurately. At work, in caregiving, or in close relationships, the same pressure appears when duty outruns choice and someone finally names what they will no longer pretend is inevitable.
"Edna plunged and swam about with an abandon that thrilled and invigorated her."
Context: After Reisz's gossip, in cooler late-season water
Body answers what conversation poisoned. Swimming becomes exorcism and reclaiming pleasure.
In Today's Words:
She swam hard enough to feel alive again after poisonous talk. Movement can reset emotion when words leave you contaminated. At work, in caregiving, or in close relationships, the same pressure appears when duty outruns choice and someone finally names what they will no longer pretend is inevitable.
Thematic Threads
Obsession
In This Chapter
Edna makes Robert the center of every conversation, even with her husband, showing how obsession warps normal social boundaries
Development
Evolved from innocent attraction to consuming fixation that distorts her reality
In Your Life:
When you find yourself steering every conversation toward one person or topic, you've crossed into obsession territory.
Longing
In This Chapter
Edna haunts Robert's mother's room, studying old photos like a detective searching for clues about who he really is
Development
Deepened from romantic interest to desperate need for connection with someone who's absent
In Your Life:
That urge to scroll through someone's social media for hours when they're not responding to your texts.
Toxic Relationships
In This Chapter
Mademoiselle Reisz delivers gossip about Robert's past disguised as helpful information, leaving Edna feeling poisoned
Development
Introduced here as a new dynamic showing how some people exploit vulnerability
In Your Life:
The friend who always has something negative to say about your romantic interests, claiming they're just looking out for you.
Reality Distortion
In This Chapter
Edna doesn't find it strange that she's obsessing over Robert in front of her own husband
Development
Progressed from small social missteps to complete disconnection from normal boundaries
In Your Life:
When your friends start giving you concerned looks about your behavior, but you can't see what they're worried about.
Emotional Escape
In This Chapter
Edna flees to the ocean, swimming desperately to wash away both the gossip and her own growing obsession
Development
Continued reliance on physical activity to manage overwhelming emotions
In Your Life:
That compulsive need to go for a drive, hit the gym, or clean the house when emotions become too much to handle.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
This is not a test. Five prompts guide you through the chapter, from how it opens to how it closes, so you notice context and rhythm rather than facts to memorize. Sit with each question in your own words. When you see "One way to read it," treat it as a starting point, not the only answer.
- 1
How does Edna pursue Robert after he leaves?
analysis • surfaceOne way to read it
She visits Madame Lebrun, studies albums, reads his letter, and prompts others including her husband to talk about him.
- 2
What does Edna mean by not giving herself?
analysis • mediumOne way to read it
She distinguishes outer sacrifice from inner identity; she will not surrender her core self to duty.
- 3
Why does Reisz's gossip depress Edna?
application • mediumOne way to read it
She wanted Robert idealized; venom about his family and Mariequita replaces fantasy with muddy reality.
- 4
How does swimming function after the conversation?
application • deepOne way to read it
Physical abandon clears emotional contamination and reclaims pleasure on her own terms.
- 5
When have you confused monitoring someone with staying connected?
reflection • deepOne way to read it
Like Edna with letters and photos, relic hunting often feeds obsession instead of healing absence.
Critical Thinking Exercise
Spot the Toxic Truth-Teller
Think of a time someone delivered painful information to you while claiming they were 'just being honest' or 'helping you.' Write down what they said, how they said it, and what happened afterward. Then analyze their true motives versus their stated motives.
Consider:
- •Did they deliver this information privately or in front of others?
- •Did they seem to enjoy your reaction or genuinely feel bad about hurting you?
- •Did they offer support or solutions, or just drop the bomb and walk away?
Journaling Prompt
Write about how you can protect yourself from toxic truth-tellers in the future. What warning signs will you watch for, and how will you respond when someone weaponizes honesty against you?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 17: The Perfect Prison
Back on Esplanade Street in their white double cottage, Edna skips Tuesday receptions without excuse and faces Léonce's lecture on les convenances before he storms out to his club and she breaks a vase in the bedroom.
