Chapter 35
The Weight of Truth and Lies
EXPIATION. “There’s nought so finely spun But it cometh to the sun.” Mr. Thornton sate on and on. He felt that his company gave pleasure to Mr. Hale; and was touched by the half-spoken wishful entreaty that he would remain a little longer—the plaintive “Don’t go yet,” which his poor friend put forth from time to time. He wondered Margaret did not return; but it was with no view of seeing her that he lingered. For the hour—and in the presence of one who was so thoroughly feeling the nothingness of earth—he was reasonable and self-controlled. He was deeply interested…
Public-domain chapter text, formatted for reading.
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"But Mr. Thornton—why did she tremble, and hide her face in the pillow?"
The question Margaret asks herself in the dark is the novel's most direct notation of her true feelings. She has been praying to a God who could read her penitence and found some comfort there; when she turns to Thornton, the body responds before the mind has given permission: she trembles and hides from the implication of what that means.
In Today's Words:
Margaret has been lying awake working through her guilt about the lie she told Thornton, and she has found some peace in the thought of divine forgiveness, because God knows the full context and can read the honest intent behind the dishonest act. But when her thoughts move to Thornton specifically, her body responds with physical agitation that she cannot immediately explain: she trembles, she hides her face. Gaskell is using this moment to show us that Margaret's feelings for Thornton have moved past what she can consciously account for, and that the body is acknowledging something the mind is not yet ready to name.
"What strong feeling had overtaken her at last? She sprang out of bed and prayed long and earnestly."
The prayer that follows Margaret's involuntary physical response to thinking about Thornton is both a moral resource and a redirect. She is using prayer to process something she cannot yet face directly: the feeling that has overtaken her is not yet named, but its power is established by her response to it.
In Today's Words:
After trembling and hiding from whatever she feels about Thornton, Margaret gets out of bed and prays, which is her most fundamental resource when she is faced with something she cannot manage by reason alone. Gaskell is careful not to name the strong feeling directly at this point, leaving it characterised only by its force and by the fact that prayer is what Margaret reaches for when confronted with it. In plain terms, something has broken through her defences, and the prayer is both an honest response to it and a way of not yet having to say aloud what it is.
"he could have borne the sense of Almighty displeasure, because He knew all, and could read her penitence, and hear her cries for help in time to come."
Margaret's relationship to divine judgement is characterised here as more bearable than human judgement precisely because it is more complete. God's knowledge includes context, intent, and future repentance; human judgement, including Thornton's, is limited to the observable fact of the lie. The preference for the comprehensive judge over the partial one is both spiritually sincere and psychologically revealing.
In Today's Words:
Margaret finds divine judgement bearable in a way she does not find Thornton's judgement bearable, and Gaskell gives us the reason: God, in Margaret's understanding, knows everything including the motive and the intent and the subsequent repentance, whereas Thornton knows only the visible act of the lie. In plain terms, she can face a judge who has access to the full picture, but she cannot face the person whose partial picture makes the worst reading possible, and the emotional truth of this distinction is more complex than simple shame: it includes the specific pain of being misread by someone whose opinion matters to her.
"almost in proportion to her re-establishment in health, was her father’s relapse into his abstracted musings upon the wife he had lost, and the past era in his life that was closed to him for ever."
The closing observation about Hale is a quiet portrait of how grief operates in a household: as one person recovers, another sinks deeper. Margaret and her father are inverse curves, and the novel notes this without comment or consolation.
In Today's Words:
Gaskell is observing, at the chapter's close, that as Margaret's physical and emotional health gradually restores itself, her father's grief deepens and becomes more absorbed. In plain terms, the household cannot grieve together or recover together because the two people remaining in it are moving in opposite directions at the same time, and neither can be attended to properly while the other also needs attending to. The closing observation refuses any comfort or resolution, noting only the fact of the double trajectory as the chapter ends.
Thematic Threads
Deception
In This Chapter
Margaret's lie about Frederick creates a web of consequences she never anticipated, ultimately revealing her true feelings about Thornton
Development
Evolved from earlier white lies and social expectations into a profound moral crisis that changes how she sees herself
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when a small lie spirals into something that forces you to confront what you really value.
Class
In This Chapter
Thornton uses his social influence to protect Margaret from legal consequences, demonstrating how power can be wielded compassionately
Development
Developed from earlier themes of class conflict into an example of how privilege can be used to protect rather than exploit
In Your Life:
You might see this when someone with more power or connections helps you navigate a system you can't handle alone.
Recognition
In This Chapter
Margaret realizes she cares desperately about Thornton's opinion, even as she tries to deny this feeling to herself
Development
Culmination of growing awareness of her feelings, forced into consciousness by crisis
In Your Life:
You might experience this when a crisis reveals feelings you've been hiding from yourself about someone important.
Protection
In This Chapter
Thornton protects Margaret not by exposing her innocence but by preventing the need for her to lie again in court
Development
Evolved from his earlier protective instincts into sophisticated understanding of what she truly needs
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when someone protects you by handling a situation quietly rather than making you prove yourself publicly.
Judgment
In This Chapter
Margaret discovers that Thornton's silent knowledge of her lie is more devastating than any formal punishment could be
Development
Built from earlier themes about social judgment into personal reckoning with whose opinion truly matters
In Your Life:
You might feel this when disappointing someone you respect hurts more than any official consequence ever could.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
This is not a test. Five prompts guide you through the chapter, from how it opens to how it closes, so you notice context and rhythm rather than facts to memorize. Sit with each question in your own words. When you see "One way to read it," treat it as a starting point, not the only answer.
- 1
Thornton apparently knows, or suspects, that Margaret was at the station, yet he uses his position to suppress the investigation. How does this action complicate his character and his feelings for Margaret?
One way to read it
Thornton's suppression of the inquiry is an act of love and an act of moral compromise: he uses institutional power to protect someone he believes has lied to him, which is not straightforward honourable behaviour. His motivation is clearly the protection of Margaret, but the action also puts him in the position of covering for a lie he disapproves of, which Gaskell uses to show that his love is complex enough to survive and override his formal principles, at significant cost to his own integrity.
- 2
Margaret finds she could 'have borne the sense of Almighty displeasure' more easily than Thornton's judgement. What does this tell us about the relative weight of divine versus human judgement in her moral world?
One way to read it
For Margaret, divine judgement is bearable because it is omniscient: a God who knows everything including her motive and her penitence cannot deliver an unjust verdict. Human judgement is harder precisely because it is partial: Thornton can only see the lie, not the full context of love and necessity that produced it. This distinction suggests that what Margaret most fears is not condemnation but being permanently misread by someone whose understanding of her genuinely matters to her, which is a distinctly social and relational fear.
- 3
When Margaret's thoughts turn to Thornton in the night, she trembles and hides her face in the pillow before she can articulate why. How does Gaskell use this involuntary bodily response to signal the state of her feelings?
One way to read it
The body's response precedes and exceeds the mind's account of itself, which is one of Gaskell's most consistent psychological techniques. Margaret has been telling herself that she feels principally guilt and shame in relation to Thornton; the tremble and the hidden face tell a different story. Gaskell places this disclosure at the moment of most acute vulnerability, alone in the dark, when the social and rational defences are weakest, which is exactly when the truth that the body knows tends to surface.
- 4
The chapter's title is 'Expiation.' Does Margaret expiate her lie by the end of the chapter, and if not, what does the title point toward?
One way to read it
Margaret does not expiate in any formal sense by the chapter's end: the lie stands, Thornton knows or suspects, and the situation has not been resolved. The title points toward the process she is beginning rather than one she has completed: the acknowledgement of wrongdoing, the prayer, the refusal to self-justify too quickly, the willingness to live with the discomfort of what she has done. Expiation in Gaskell's moral universe is not a single event but an ongoing orientation toward honesty about one's own failures.
- 5
The chapter ends with the observation that as Margaret recovers, her father sinks deeper into grief. What is Gaskell saying about the impossibility of simultaneous recovery in a household that has suffered multiple losses?
One way to read it
Gaskell is recording a simple and painful truth about shared domestic space: grief is not synchronised, and the recovery of one person can leave another feeling the absence more sharply rather than less. Margaret's returning health makes her a visible presence again in the house, which is exactly what highlights her father's loss. The chapter ends without resolution on this point, which is appropriate: there is no solution available to it, only the slow mutual accommodation that grief eventually produces in families that survive it.
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Respect Compass
List three people whose disappointment would genuinely devastate you - not anger you, embarrass you, or inconvenience you, but truly wound you. For each person, write what quality or achievement they represent that you aspire to. Then consider: are you living in a way that honors what their respect means to you?
Consider:
- •Focus on people whose opinion cuts deep because of who they are, not what they can do for you
- •Notice if these people share common qualities that reveal your core values
- •Consider whether fear of their disappointment is helping or hindering your growth
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when someone you respected caught you falling short of your own standards. How did their knowledge of your failure change how you saw yourself, and what did you learn about what really matters to you?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 36: When Principles Collide With Tragedy
As Margaret struggles with her damaged reputation in Thornton's eyes, the consequences of recent events continue to ripple through both their lives, forcing difficult reckonings with pride and prejudice. The opening of CHAPTER XXXVI. will force Margaret to act faster than she expected, and the choice she makes there will echo through every relationship still ahead..
