A grab is priced by what was grabbed, not by a school's favourite multiple, and the first person to shout is not the one who was hurt. Sudden direct seizure is sahasa; fraudulent seizure is theft. Manu wants a fine equal to value; Usanas wants twice. Kautilya wants proportion to gravity: flowers and pots twelve to twenty-four panas, iron and minor herds twenty-four to forty-eight, copper and ivory up to the first amercement, men, fields, houses, and gold the middlemost. Forcing prison or breaking it is the highest. The planner who uses a hireling pays twice. Defamation then runs by caste: abuse upward increases the fine; abuse downward decreases it. Intimidation without the act is half. A person who can harm, and hates, must give lifelong security. Insult of nation or village is the first amercement; of caste or assembly the middlemost; of gods or temples the highest.
A blow is touching, striking, or hurting. Teachers want old quarrels dropped, and the first complainant to win because pain drives a person to law. Kautilya refuses both. There is no acquittal for an offender. First or last, witnesses decide; without them, the hurt itself. Sentence falls the day the accused of assault will not answer. Theft under the tumult of a quarrel is ten panas. A knocked wall is three; breaking it is six plus restoration.
Gambling is a watch. The superintendent centralises play, on a twelve-pana fine if it is done elsewhere, so spies and thieves have one room to be found in. He takes hire for dice, water, and lodging, and the licence. If he does not stop tricks of hand, he pays twice the gamblers' fine. Pilgrims, ascetics, the sick, the hungry, the tired, villagers, the over-punished, and the penniless are shown mercy. Cases of gods, Brahmans, ascetics, women, minors, the aged, the diseased, and the helpless are settled by judges even without a complaint. Learned, brave, or high-born persons are honoured. Judges settle free of circumvention, mind unchanged, pleasing and affable to all. Book III ends. Book IV will pull thorns that never filed a case.
Coming Up in Chapter 21
Three commissioners will suppress disturbance to peace. Weavers, goldsmiths, and merchants who sell inferior as superior will be fined. Then floods, famine, and tigers, and a king who must protect the afflicted as a father his sons.