The Messenger's Dilemma — The Age of Innocence

Archer returns from his emotional meeting with Ellen feeling surprisingly calm and resolved. He understands that Ellen would only return to Europe if she felt she was becoming too much of a temptation for him, putting the power to keep her safe entirely in his hands. Back in New York, he encounters M. Riviere, the young Frenchman who had been the Carfry family's tutor in London.

What starts as a chance meeting becomes a shocking revelation: Riviere has been sent by Count Olenski as a messenger to convince Ellen to return to her husband. But here's the twist, after meeting with Ellen and seeing how she's changed in America, Riviere has completely switched sides. He's now desperately trying to convince Archer and the family NOT to let Ellen go back.

Riviere explains that Ellen has become truly American in her values, making the compromises expected in European high society 'simply unthinkable' for her. The Count's desire to have her back isn't about love, it's far more complicated than that.

Most disturbing for Archer is learning that the Mingott family has been negotiating Ellen's future without consulting him, having sensed he's no longer 'on their side.' Even his own wife May has been part of this silent conspiracy. Riviere, knowing his confession will cost him his job, makes one final plea: don't let Ellen return to a life that will destroy her American soul.