Chapter 05
When Friends Disagree About Friends
“I do not know what your opinion may be, Mrs. Weston,” said Mr. Knightley, “of this great intimacy between Emma and Harriet Smith, but I think it a bad thing.” “A bad thing! Do you really think it a bad thing?—why so?” “I think they will neither of them do the other any good.” “You surprize me! Emma must do Harriet good: and by supplying her with a new object of interest, Harriet may be said to do Emma good. I have been seeing their intimacy with the greatest pleasure. How very differently we feel!—Not think they will do each…
Public-domain chapter text, formatted for reading.
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"I think they will neither of them do the other any good."
Context: Opening his case against the Emma-Harriet intimacy
Knightley names harm for both women at once. Mrs. Weston hears only benefit; the chapter turns on which reading of the same friendship is right.
In Today's Words:
Knightley tells Mrs Weston plainly that Emma and Harriet will hurt each other, not help. He opens their quarrel by refusing her cheerful picture of the friendship before he ever names flattery, class, reading lists, or the hourly undesigned praise Harriet gives without knowing she flatters.
"Her ignorance is hourly flattery."
Context: Describing Harriet's effect on Emma
Harriet does not mean to flatter, which makes the damage harder to see. Emma feels admired without being corrected.
In Today's Words:
Knightley says Harriet flatters Emma every hour simply by knowing nothing and treating her as knowing everything. The praise is constant and undesigned, so Emma never feels challenged while she plays teacher to a girl who cannot gain by the acquaintance and will be spoiled for her real station.
"I am not to be talked out of my dislike of Harriet Smith, or my dread of its doing them both harm."
Context: After Mrs. Weston praises Emma's beauty
Complimenting Emma's person cannot settle the argument. Knightley keeps his worry about the friendship fixed.
In Today's Words:
Even after Mrs Weston gushes over Emma's beauty, health, and hazel eye, Knightley says he will not be argued out of disliking Harriet Smith or fearing the friendship harms them both. A pretty face does not answer his point about mind, flattery, influence, and what Hartfield will do to Harriet.
"I wonder what will become of her!"
Context: After promising not to spread an outcry about the intimacy
Knightley ends not with a verdict but with open anxiety. His care outlasts the quarrel he agrees to drop.
In Today's Words:
Knightley promises Mrs Weston he will keep his ill humour private and not alarm Isabella, then admits his deep curiosity about Emma's future. He loves her enough to quarrel over Harriet and enough to wonder where her unchecked confidence and hourly flattery will finally lead.
Thematic Threads
Class
In This Chapter
Knightley worries that Emma's friendship with Harriet will give both women false ideas about their social positions—Emma feeling superior, Harriet feeling entitled to more than her birth allows
Development
Deepening from earlier hints about social boundaries to explicit concern about cross-class friendships disrupting natural order
In Your Life:
You might see this when workplace friendships cross hierarchical lines and create tension about boundaries and expectations
Personal Growth
In This Chapter
Knightley identifies Emma's core problem: she's never faced real difficulty or had anyone challenge her, leaving her unprepared for life's realities
Development
Building on previous chapters' hints about Emma's sheltered existence to reveal the deeper consequences of unchallenged privilege
In Your Life:
You recognize this in yourself or others who've been protected from consequences and struggle when reality finally hits
Human Relationships
In This Chapter
The disagreement between Knightley and Mrs. Weston shows two different ways of loving someone—through confrontation versus through support
Development
Introduced here as a new dimension of how people who care about the same person can have completely different approaches
In Your Life:
You see this in how different family members or friends handle your problems—some challenge you, others enable you
Identity
In This Chapter
Emma's sense of self is built on constant admiration and lack of challenge, making her identity fragile and untested
Development
Evolving from earlier suggestions that Emma might be overconfident to revealing the psychological foundation of her self-image
In Your Life:
You might recognize this in yourself or others whose confidence crumbles when faced with real criticism or failure
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
This is not a test. Five prompts guide you through the chapter, from how it opens to how it closes, so you notice context and rhythm rather than facts to memorize. Sit with each question in your own words. When you see "One way to read it," treat it as a starting point, not the only answer.
- 1
What is Knightley's opening verdict on the Emma-Harriet intimacy?
analysis • surfaceOne way to read it
He thinks it a bad thing and says they will neither of them do the other any good.
- 2
Why does Knightley doubt Emma's reading plans with Harriet?
analysis • mediumOne way to read it
Emma has made good book lists since childhood but never sustains steady reading; Harriet will stimulate her less than Miss Taylor did.
- 3
How does Knightley describe Harriet's effect on Emma's sense of herself?
application • mediumOne way to read it
Harriet knows nothing, treats Emma as knowing everything, and her ignorance is hourly flattery that keeps Emma from learning.
- 4
Why does Mrs. Weston urge Knightley not to make the intimacy a topic of open discussion?
application • deepOne way to read it
Emma answers only to her approving father and enjoys the friendship; Mrs. Weston says no good can come of wider talk and Isabella might be alarmed.
- 5
When have you heard two people who care about someone disagree about whether to intervene?
reflection • deepOne way to read it
One honest answer might recall a family or friend debate like Knightley and Mrs. Weston, where one names risk and the other defends present happiness.
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Support Network
Draw or list the people in your life who fill different roles: who tells you hard truths (your Knightleys), who offers unconditional support (your Mrs. Westons), and who just agrees with everything you say. Then think about which type of friend you are to others. Are there gaps in your network or patterns in how you show up for people?
Consider:
- •Notice if you're missing either truth-tellers or supporters - both are necessary
- •Consider whether you avoid people who challenge you or only seek out those who agree
- •Think about whether you default to being supportive or challenging - and when each is most helpful
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when someone loved you enough to tell you something you didn't want to hear. How did you react in the moment, and how do you feel about it now? What did you learn about yourself from that experience?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 6: The Portrait Project Begins
Chapter VI finds Emma sure she has directed Harriet toward Elton: she praises his admiration, proposes Harriet's portrait, and Elton eagerly offers to carry the drawing to London for framing.
