Chapter 28
The Price of Division
Who, e’en in words unfetter’d, might at full Tell of the wounds and blood that now I saw, Though he repeated oft the tale? No tongue So vast a theme could equal, speech and thought Both impotent alike. If in one band Collected, stood the people all, who e’er Pour’d on Apulia’s happy soil their blood, Slain by the Trojans, and in that long war When of the rings the measur’d booty made A pile so high, as Rome’s historian writes Who errs not, with the multitude, that felt The grinding force of Guiscard’s Norman steel, And those the rest,…
Public-domain chapter text from Project Gutenberg, formatted for reading.
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"A rundlet, that hath lost Its middle or side stave, gapes not so wide, As one I mark’d, torn from the chin throughout Down to the hinder passage: ’twixt the legs Dangling his entrails hung, the midriff lay Open to view, and wretched ventricle, That turns th’ englutted aliment to dross."
Context: Dante's first sight of the ninth chasm — the comparison used to describe the split man
Dante uses a broken barrel to describe a man split open from chin to groin. The comparison makes the horrific damage seem precise and measurable.
In Today's Words:
A broken wine barrel with missing slats doesn't gape as wide as this person I saw, split from chin down through his entire torso, intestines hanging between his legs, stomach and digestive organs completely exposed to view. Dante uses a broken barrel to describe a man split open from chin to groin.
"Now mark how I do rip me! lo! How is Mohammed mangled! before me Walks Ali weeping, from the chin his face Cleft to the forelock; and the others all Whom here thou seest, while they liv’d, did sow Scandal and schism, and therefore thus are rent."
Context: Mohammed identifying himself and Ali, and explaining the principle of the punishment
Mohammed demonstrates his punishment by tearing himself open before Dante's eyes. He explains that those who created religious or political divisions are themselves eternally divided.
In Today's Words:
See how I tear myself open! Look how Mohammed is mangled! Ali walks ahead, his face split from chin to hairline. All of us here created scandal and division in life, so now we're permanently torn apart. Mohammed demonstrates his punishment by tearing himself open before Dante's eyes.
"Remember thee Of Mosca, too, I who, alas! exclaim’d, ‘The deed once done there is an end,’ that prov’d A seed of sorrow to the Tuscan race.”"
Context: Mosca quoting the counsel he gave in life that started the Buondelmonte feud
Mosca recalls giving fatal advice that started a blood feud between Florentine families. His brief counsel about finishing what was started caused generations of violence and death.
In Today's Words:
Remember Mosca too, who said 'Once the deed is done, there's an end to it' when they asked about killing the groom. Those words became the seed of endless sorrow for all Tuscan families. Mosca recalls giving fatal advice that started a blood feud between Florentine families.
"For parting those so closely knit, my brain Parted, alas! I carry from its source, That in this trunk inhabits. Thus the law Of retribution fiercely works in me.”"
Context: Bertrand's closing self-explanation, head in hand
Bertrand explains that because he separated father and son in life, his head is now separated from his body. He recognizes this as divine justice working perfectly through his punishment.
In Today's Words:
Because I divided those who were closely united as family, my brain is now divided from my body that houses it. This is how the law of retribution operates fiercely and precisely within me. Bertrand explains that because he separated father and son in life, his head is now separated from his body.
Thematic Threads
Manipulation
In This Chapter
Souls who manipulated others into conflict now experience physical separation and fragmentation
Development
Evolved from earlier deceptions to show manipulation's ultimate cost to the manipulator
In Your Life:
When you catch yourself stirring up drama between friends or coworkers, recognize you're training yourself to see relationships as games rather than connections
Consequences
In This Chapter
Punishments precisely mirror the crimes—those who divided others are themselves eternally divided
Development
Continues the pattern of punishments fitting the spiritual damage caused by sins
In Your Life:
The way you treat others shapes who you become, often in ways you don't notice until the damage is done
Communication
In This Chapter
Souls desperately try to send warnings to the living world about the true cost of their actions
Development
Builds on earlier themes of failed communication and missed opportunities for redemption
In Your Life:
Pay attention when people warn you about destructive patterns—they may be speaking from hard-won experience
Identity
In This Chapter
The punishment of carrying one's own severed head shows how division fractures the self
Development
Deepens exploration of how sin distorts and fragments human identity
In Your Life:
When you feel internally conflicted or 'at war with yourself,' consider whether you've been creating similar conflicts in your relationships
Power
In This Chapter
Religious and political figures who abused their influence to create schisms face the most severe torments
Development
Continues examination of how authority can be corrupted and the responsibility that comes with influence
In Your Life:
Whatever influence you have—as parent, supervisor, or community member—using it to divide people ultimately undermines your own authority
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
This is not a test. Five prompts guide you through the chapter, from how it opens to how it closes, so you notice context and rhythm rather than facts to memorize. Sit with each question in your own words. When you see "One way to read it," treat it as a starting point, not the only answer.
- 1
Why are the sowers of discord split open and healed on a repeating circuit?
analysis • surfaceOne way to read it
The ninth chasm holds the sowers of discord, and Dante opens with a challenge to his own language: no tongue could describe what he saw, not even if you assembled every battlefield casualty from Apulia's history.
- 2
What warning does Mohammed deliver to Fra Dolcino, and why?
analysis • mediumOne way to read it
Before he moves on, Mohammed delivers a warning for Fra Dolcino: stock up on food or the snows of Novara will finish you. It identifies itself: Mohammed, and in front of him Ali, his face cleft to the forelock.
- 3
Why does Mosca de' Lamberti say 'What is done is done' ruin Florence?
application • mediumOne way to read it
In life he told the Amidei clan that 'the deed once done, there is an end' , the counsel that triggered the first murder in the Buondelmonte feud and seeded generations of Florentine civil war. Mosca said four words that launched a blood feud; his hands , the instruments of gesture, of pointing, of urging , are gone.
- 4
Why is Bertrand de Born punished with his severed head carried as a lamp?
application • deepOne way to read it
Last is Bertrand de Born, carrying his own severed head like a lantern. Bertrand set a father and son at war; his head and body are at war with each other, and he has to carry the evidence.
- 5
When have you seen someone who divided others pay with their own fragmentation?
reflection • deepOne way to read it
Last is Bertrand de Born, carrying his own severed head like a lantern. He held it up by the hair so the head could speak. He turned father and son against each other — King Henry II and his son Prince John — as Ahitophel turned Absalom against David. For severing what was joined, his head is severed from its body. The law of retribution, he says, fiercely works in me. Consider when you seen someone who divided others pay with their own fragmentation and what the canto would have you notice about that moment.
Critical Thinking Exercise
Track the Discord Pattern
Think of someone you know who frequently creates drama or turns people against each other. Map out what they gain from this behavior and what they lose. Then consider: what might they really be seeking underneath the conflict-creation? What healthier ways could they meet those needs?
Consider:
- •Look for what the person gains: attention, feeling important, avoiding their own problems
- •Notice what they lose: genuine friendships, trust, peace of mind
- •Consider what they might actually need: connection, validation, control over their own life
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you found yourself stirring up conflict or drama. What were you really trying to accomplish? How did it affect your relationships and your own sense of integrity?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 29: The Weight of Unfinished Business
Dante struggles to process the overwhelming horror he's witnessed, as the sheer multitude of mutilated souls threatens to break his spirit. The journey through Hell's depths continues to test not just his courage, but his very sanity.
